Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

Unintended consequences of Health Care Quality Improvement Act: a violation of physicians’ civil and constitutional rights

Farid Gharagozloo, MD & Rainer Gruessner, MD & Robert Poston, MD
Physician
March 13, 2023
7 Shares
Share
Tweet
Share

The Black Lives Matter and Me Too movements, as well as the Human Rights Campaign for the LGBTQ+ community, are a few examples of where American democracy and values have triumphed in restoring dignity and civil and constitutional rights to marginalized individuals. Although much work remains to be done, the enlightenment brought about by these movements will undoubtedly continue to strengthen American democracy. However, it is concerning that during the same time period, America’s physicians have faced increasing deprivation of their civil and constitutional rights by the federal government.

To quote Paul Harvey, “Here is the rest of the story.”

In 1986, the U.S. Congress passed the Health Care Quality Improvement Act of 1986 (HCQIA). HCQIA was designed to protect the health and safety of the public by 1) enhancing the peer review process through protection for peer review members from lawsuits and 2) providing a national repository for reported information regarding medical malpractice payments and adverse actions involving physicians.

HCQIA became law as the medical system was undergoing a significant organizational change. In 1986, most physicians were private practitioners who practiced in hospitals by virtue of holding privileges at that hospital. In the 1980s, there was effectively an organizational and administrative wall between medical staff office governance and the hospital administration. Fast forward to the drastic changes in the health care system since 1986. In 2023, health care has been consolidated into increasingly larger hospital organizations, payment for health care services has become consolidated under more powerful governmental and private insurance carriers, and the majority of physicians are now employed. In 2023, peer review committees in most hospital organizations are appointed by the medical staff offices, which are part of the hospital administration. The proceedings are conducted in secrecy and under the immunity provisions of HCQIA, and the presiding judge and jurors are chosen and paid by the hospital administration. As a result, many concerns have been raised about potential anticompetitive behavior by some hospitals, who may engage in “sham peer review” under the protection of HCQIA.

While sham peer review is a subject of vigorous debate, it concerns part of the provisions under HCQIA. However, the consequences of reporting adverse actions by the National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) have violated physicians’ constitutional and civil rights.

NPDB is an agency of the federal government under the jurisdiction of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The NPDB publishes the reports from hospitals without an independent federal investigation. The framers of HCQIA did not foresee that in 2023, hospitals and employers will invariably deny employment or hospital privileges based on an NPDB report outlining loss of hospital privileges or relinquishment of hospital privileges under investigation. Such an adverse report by NPDB results in the inability of the physician to obtain employment or practice in a hospital.   Therefore, in 2023, the unintended consequence of mere reporting by NPDB without further investigation or due Process by HHS, an agency of the federal government, violates physicians’ constitutional and civil rights.

The NPDB reporting provision of HCQIA violates the Constitution’s fifth, eighth, ninth, and tenth amendments.

1. Fifth Amendment: right to due process. Under HCQIA and state laws, the peer review proceedings are confidential and privileged. In the context of all this secrecy, the peer review process often lacks reasonable and fair procedures, does not provide any discovery for the physician, does not allow the accused  to compel witnesses to testify, places the burden of proof on the accused, and ignores conflict of interest. Since HHS does not perform an independent investigation, the NPDB report is in violation of the Fifth Amendment.

2. Eighth Amendment: cruel and unusual punishment. In 2022, over 1,000 U.S. physicians had a report filed in the NPDB indicating their hospital privileges were revoked. This action officially blacklists a physician as untouchable by all other hospitals, medical boards, insurance carriers, and other entities important to a physician’s career. A physician’s career is terminated without the ability to obtain privileges at other hospitals. A report of revoking privileges without due process, which results in the termination of a physician’s career, amounts to cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth Amendment.

3. Ninth Amendment: Rights granted by state laws cannot be preempted by federal laws under the Supremacy Clause. The physician is licensed to practice medicine under state law. The effect of adverse reporting by NPDB, a federal agency, is to prevent the physician from exercising his rights authorized by the state medical license.

4. Tenth Amendment: The powers not delegated to the federal government by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively. As in the case of Ninth Amendment, adverse reporting by NPDB, a federal agency, which prevents the physician from exercising his rights under the state license represents a violation of the Tenth Amendment.

There is a dire need for legal action and a corresponding insurance product to reclaim the constitutional rights for all physicians. After all, protecting the physician community ultimately translates to better care for the public. American investigational journalists need to shine a light on these egregious violations of physicians’ civil and constitutional rights. It is time to acknowledge that physicians’ lives matter too.

Farid Gharagozloo is a cardiothoracic surgeon, professor of surgery, and surgeon-in-chief at the Institute For Advanced Thoracic Surgery, University of Central Florida College of Medicine, and UCF Lake Nona Hospital.

Robert Poston is a cardiothoracic surgeon.

Rainer Gruessner is a transplant surgeon.

Prev

We need a new approach to Black mental health

March 13, 2023 Kevin 0
…
Next

From tragedy to advocacy: a journey through medical errors [PODCAST]

March 13, 2023 Kevin 0
…

Tagged as: Public Health & Policy

Post navigation

< Previous Post
We need a new approach to Black mental health
Next Post >
From tragedy to advocacy: a journey through medical errors [PODCAST]

Related Posts

  • How social media can help or hurt your health care career

    Health eCareers
  • Physicians and patients must work together to improve health care

    Michele Luckenbaugh
  • Physicians have become devalued in modern health care

    Anonymous
  • Writing tips for physicians from a health care editor

    Debra A. Shute
  • Are physicians ready for single-payer health care?

    Bob Doherty
  • Health care is not a service commodity

    Peter Spence, MD, MBA

More in Physician

  • The hidden factor in physician burnout: How the climate crisis is contributing to the erosion of well-being

    Elizabeth Cerceo, MD
  • Raw humanity on night float: inspiring patient encounters and overcoming challenges

    Johnathan Yao, MD, MPH
  • Revolutionizing emergency medicine: Overcoming long-term challenges with innovative solutions for physicians and patients

    Anonymous
  • The pediatric health care system tested to the limits: an inside look at the “at capacity” period during the tripledemic

    Jacqueline Bolt, MD
  • How chronic illness and disability are portrayed in media and the importance of daily choices for improved quality of life

    Juliet Morgan and Meghan Jobson
  • How biased language and stigmatizing labels affect patient care and treatment

    Joan Naidorf, DO
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • A patient’s perspective on the diminishing relationship between doctors and patients

      Michele Luckenbaugh | Conditions
    • Unmasking wage disparity in health care: the truth behind the Elmhurst Hospital physician strike

      Kevin Pho, MD | KevinMD
    • Why affirmative action is crucial for health equity and social justice in medicine

      Katrina Gipson, MD, MPH | Policy
    • How electronic health records preserve patients’ legacies in the words of oncologists

      Marc Braunstein, MD, PhD | Physician
    • Unmasking the brutal reality of gun violence in America: a call to action for unity and meaningful change

      Osmund Agbo, MD | Policy
    • Emulating Michael Jordan’s winning mindset: a path to success for health care professionals and entrepreneurs

      Harvey Castro, MD, MBA | Physician
  • Past 6 Months

    • The growing threat to transgender health care: implications for patients, providers, and trainees

      Carson Hartlage | Policy
    • Breaking point: the 5 reasons American doctors are dreaming of walking away from medicine

      Amol Shrikhande, MD | Physician
    • “Is your surgeon really skilled? The hidden threat to public safety in medicine.

      Gene Uzawa Dorio, MD | Physician
    • It’s time to replace the 0 to 10 pain intensity scale with a better measure

      Mark Sullivan, MD and Jane Ballantyne, MD | Conditions
    • Breaking the cycle of racism in health care: a call for anti-racist action

      Tomi Mitchell, MD | Policy
    • Revolutionize your practice: the value-based care model that reduces physician burnout

      Chandravadan Patel, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • The hidden factor in physician burnout: How the climate crisis is contributing to the erosion of well-being

      Elizabeth Cerceo, MD | Physician
    • The surprising medical mystery of a “good” Hitler: How a rescued kitten revealed a rare movement disorder

      Teresella Gondolo, MD | Conditions
    • The power of coaching for physicians: transforming thoughts, changing lives

      Kim Downey, PT | Conditions
    • Why doctors aren’t to blame for the U.S. opioid crisis [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Raw humanity on night float: inspiring patient encounters and overcoming challenges

      Johnathan Yao, MD, MPH | Physician
    • Is AI the solution for the shortage of nephrologists? ChatGPT weighs in.

      Amol Shrikhande, MD | Tech

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

View 3 Comments >

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

CME Spotlights

From MedPage Today

Latest News

  • Want to Solve the Nurse Shortage?
  • Why Are Female Doctors Sued Nearly Half as Often as Male Doctors?
  • What Drug Did FDA Just Approve for COVID?
  • PET Scan for Alzheimer's Dx; Predicting Colon Cancer Survival
  • What Happens When We Classify Kids' Weight as a 'Disease'?

Meeting Coverage

  • No Access to Routine Healthcare Biggest Barrier to HPV Vaccination
  • Trial Results Spark Talk of Curing More Metastatic Cervical Cancers
  • Cross-Border Collaboration Improves Survival in Pediatric Leukemia Patients
  • Monoclonal Antibody Reduced Need For Transfusions in Low-Risk MDS
  • Less-Invasive Surgery for Pancreatic Cancer Proves Safe, Effective
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • A patient’s perspective on the diminishing relationship between doctors and patients

      Michele Luckenbaugh | Conditions
    • Unmasking wage disparity in health care: the truth behind the Elmhurst Hospital physician strike

      Kevin Pho, MD | KevinMD
    • Why affirmative action is crucial for health equity and social justice in medicine

      Katrina Gipson, MD, MPH | Policy
    • How electronic health records preserve patients’ legacies in the words of oncologists

      Marc Braunstein, MD, PhD | Physician
    • Unmasking the brutal reality of gun violence in America: a call to action for unity and meaningful change

      Osmund Agbo, MD | Policy
    • Emulating Michael Jordan’s winning mindset: a path to success for health care professionals and entrepreneurs

      Harvey Castro, MD, MBA | Physician
  • Past 6 Months

    • The growing threat to transgender health care: implications for patients, providers, and trainees

      Carson Hartlage | Policy
    • Breaking point: the 5 reasons American doctors are dreaming of walking away from medicine

      Amol Shrikhande, MD | Physician
    • “Is your surgeon really skilled? The hidden threat to public safety in medicine.

      Gene Uzawa Dorio, MD | Physician
    • It’s time to replace the 0 to 10 pain intensity scale with a better measure

      Mark Sullivan, MD and Jane Ballantyne, MD | Conditions
    • Breaking the cycle of racism in health care: a call for anti-racist action

      Tomi Mitchell, MD | Policy
    • Revolutionize your practice: the value-based care model that reduces physician burnout

      Chandravadan Patel, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • The hidden factor in physician burnout: How the climate crisis is contributing to the erosion of well-being

      Elizabeth Cerceo, MD | Physician
    • The surprising medical mystery of a “good” Hitler: How a rescued kitten revealed a rare movement disorder

      Teresella Gondolo, MD | Conditions
    • The power of coaching for physicians: transforming thoughts, changing lives

      Kim Downey, PT | Conditions
    • Why doctors aren’t to blame for the U.S. opioid crisis [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Raw humanity on night float: inspiring patient encounters and overcoming challenges

      Johnathan Yao, MD, MPH | Physician
    • Is AI the solution for the shortage of nephrologists? ChatGPT weighs in.

      Amol Shrikhande, MD | Tech

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

Unintended consequences of Health Care Quality Improvement Act: a violation of physicians’ civil and constitutional rights
3 comments

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...