Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

The ethical breach surrounding the first test tube baby

Peter Ubel, MD
Physician
February 22, 2013
416 Shares
Share
Tweet
Share

The first test tube baby was born July 25th, 1978 in the north of England.  Louise Brown was called the “baby of the century” by some and a “moral abomination” by others.  It wasn’t Brown who critics accused of being immoral, of course.  She was just a blameless infant.  Instead, it was her doctors who came under fire for their new fertility treatment—in vitro fertilization (or IVF).  Roman Catholic theologians characterized this treatment as “unnatural”.  Bioethicists fretted about the risk such treatments posed for mothers and children.

But all these critics of IVF missed the true immorality behind Louise Brown’s birth.  Brown’s doctors never told her mother that IVF was a brand new procedure!

The uproar at the time of Louise Brown’s birth was understandable.  This was a brand new way of having a baby after all.  The baby was not conceived inside Brown’s womb.  The unnaturalness of this procedure was scary for many people.  And the fact that the baby would begin in a test tube, an environment very different than inside a woman’s body, raised all kinds of understandable fears about what this would do to the developing fetus.  Within a decade, the medical facts about IVF relieved most people’s fears about the safety of the procedure.  IVF gained moral acceptance too, even from most practicing Roman Catholics.  (It has become a bit like birth control—accepted by the flock, pilloried by the shepherds.)  But with the death this year of Lesley Brown, Louise’s mother, I came to learn about the actual immorality surrounding the birth of the first test tube baby.  I discovered that Brown was never told that she was undergoing an experimental treatment.

As described recently in the New York Times Magazine , Brown’s gynecologist was a man named Patrick Steptoe.  Brown had come to him because her fallopian tubes were blocked, preventing her from becoming pregnant.  An earlier surgery had failed to unblock the tubes, but she was still hoping to find a way to have her own child.  Steptoe explained that Brown could still have a baby if she wanted to undergo what he called “an implant.”  She agreed to undergo the procedure without any awareness that the treatment was both experimental and unprecedented.

She decided to go ahead with the implant without any idea that the risks and benefits of the procedure were unknown to her and to her baby.

And of course she went along with Steptoe’s recommendation completely unaware that she and her baby (if the procedure worked!) would be thrust into the center of an international media maelstrom.

By 1977, when Brown and Steptoe (oh so briefly) discussed whether to proceed with the procedure, medical experts had already reached a consensus that physicians need to inform patients about the risks and benefits of treatments before making treatment choices.  Indeed, common sense and common decency would have demanded better disclosure of the novelty of this treatment.  It’s hard to fathom the level of … of arrogance? of ambition? … that would have blinded Steptoe to his moral duty to inform Brown about the enormous uncertainty surrounding the new procedure.

Indeed, medical practitioners had already become familiar with a series of atrocities at the hands of ambitious medical researchers.  I tell some of these stories in my book Critical Decisions, stories of physicians injecting unsuspecting patients with hepatitis viruses—and even cancer cells!—to learn more about the “natural history” of these diseases.  But many of these cases occurred decades earlier than Brown’s pregnancy, and when details of these cases came to light, medical practitioners were duly warned that they should not experiment in patients without their patients’ informed consent.

IVF was controversial in 1978 because it was a newfangled, high tech treatment: one that further separated procreation from the, um, procreative act, and one that hinted at a science fiction-like future where babies could be grown outside a mother’s womb.

Interesting to learn in retrospect that the real ethical breach surrounding the first test tube baby was a good old fashioned failure to achieve informed consent.

Peter Ubel is a physician and behavioral scientist who blogs at his self-titled site, Peter Ubel and can be reached on Twitter @PeterUbel.  He is the author of Critical Decisions: How You and Your Doctor Can Make the Right Medical Choices Together.

Prev

Filling out a death certificate: A better way is needed

February 22, 2013 Kevin 9
…
Next

Why the American problem with opioids and chronic pain is here to stay

February 22, 2013 Kevin 42
…

Tagged as: OB/GYN

Post navigation

< Previous Post
Filling out a death certificate: A better way is needed
Next Post >
Why the American problem with opioids and chronic pain is here to stay

More by Peter Ubel, MD

  • Clinicians shouldn’t be punished for taking care of needy populations

    Peter Ubel, MD
  • Patients alone cannot combat high health care prices

    Peter Ubel, MD
  • Is the FDA too slow to handle the pandemic?

    Peter Ubel, MD

More in Physician

  • The hidden gems of health care: Unlocking the potential of narrative medicine

    Dr. Najat Fadlallah
  • The dark side of immortality: What if we could live forever?

    Ketan Desai, MD, PhD
  • It’s time for C-suite to contract directly with physicians for part-time work

    Aaron Morgenstein, MD & Corinne Sundar Rao, MD
  • From rural communities to underserved populations: How telemedicine is bridging health care gaps

    Harvey Castro, MD, MBA
  • From solidarity to co-liberation: Understanding the journey towards ending oppression

    Maiysha Clairborne, MD
  • Finding peace through surrender: a personal exploration

    Dympna Weil, MD
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • Nobody wants this job. Should physicians stick around?

      Katie Klingberg, MD | Physician
    • Healing the damaged nurse-physician dynamic

      Angel J. Mena, MD and Ali Morin, MSN, RN | Policy
    • The struggle to fill emergency medicine residency spots: Exploring the factors behind the unfilled match

      Katrina Gipson, MD, MPH | Physician
    • Deaths of despair: an urgent call for a collective response to the crisis in U.S. life expectancy

      Mohammed Umer Waris, MD | Policy
    • Breaking the stigma: Addressing the struggles of physicians

      Jean Antonucci, MD | Physician
  • Past 6 Months

    • The hidden dangers of the Nebraska Heartbeat Act

      Meghan Sheehan, MD | Policy
    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • The vital importance of climate change education in medical schools

      Helen Kim, MD | Policy
    • The fight for reproductive health: Why medication abortion matters

      Catherine Hennessey, MD | Physician
    • Nobody wants this job. Should physicians stick around?

      Katie Klingberg, MD | Physician
    • Resetting the doctor-patient relationship: Navigating the challenges of modern primary care

      Jeffrey H. Millstein, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • The hidden gems of health care: Unlocking the potential of narrative medicine

      Dr. Najat Fadlallah | Physician
    • The realities of immigrant health care served hot from America’s melting pot

      Stella Cho | Policy
    • The dark side of immortality: What if we could live forever?

      Ketan Desai, MD, PhD | Physician
    • Lazarus: the dead man brought back to life

      William Lynes, MD | Conditions
    • Revolutionizing COPD management with virtual care solutions [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • What I think it means to be a medical student in the wake of AI

      Jackson J. McCue | Tech

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

View 3 Comments >

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

CME Spotlights

From MedPage Today

Latest News

  • Functional Neurological Disorder Emerges After COVID Infection, Vaccines
  • Neuromodulation of the Peroneal Nerve Safe for Overactive Bladder
  • Clinical Challenges: Test Your Knowledge of Atopic Dermatitis
  • Clinical Challenges: Atopic Dermatitis Is Not Just a Skin Disease
  • Our Organ Transplant System Isn't the Failure It's Made Out to Be

Meeting Coverage

  • Switch to IL-23 Blocker Yields Deep Responses in Recalcitrant Plaque Psoriasis
  • Biomarkers of Response With Enfortumab Vedotin in Advanced Urothelial Cancer
  • At-Home Topical Therapy for Molluscum Contagiosum Gets High Marks
  • Outlook for Itchy Prurigo Nodularis Continues to Improve With IL-31 Antagonist
  • AAAAI President Shares Highlights From the 2023 Meeting
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • Nobody wants this job. Should physicians stick around?

      Katie Klingberg, MD | Physician
    • Healing the damaged nurse-physician dynamic

      Angel J. Mena, MD and Ali Morin, MSN, RN | Policy
    • The struggle to fill emergency medicine residency spots: Exploring the factors behind the unfilled match

      Katrina Gipson, MD, MPH | Physician
    • Deaths of despair: an urgent call for a collective response to the crisis in U.S. life expectancy

      Mohammed Umer Waris, MD | Policy
    • Breaking the stigma: Addressing the struggles of physicians

      Jean Antonucci, MD | Physician
  • Past 6 Months

    • The hidden dangers of the Nebraska Heartbeat Act

      Meghan Sheehan, MD | Policy
    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • The vital importance of climate change education in medical schools

      Helen Kim, MD | Policy
    • The fight for reproductive health: Why medication abortion matters

      Catherine Hennessey, MD | Physician
    • Nobody wants this job. Should physicians stick around?

      Katie Klingberg, MD | Physician
    • Resetting the doctor-patient relationship: Navigating the challenges of modern primary care

      Jeffrey H. Millstein, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • The hidden gems of health care: Unlocking the potential of narrative medicine

      Dr. Najat Fadlallah | Physician
    • The realities of immigrant health care served hot from America’s melting pot

      Stella Cho | Policy
    • The dark side of immortality: What if we could live forever?

      Ketan Desai, MD, PhD | Physician
    • Lazarus: the dead man brought back to life

      William Lynes, MD | Conditions
    • Revolutionizing COPD management with virtual care solutions [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • What I think it means to be a medical student in the wake of AI

      Jackson J. McCue | Tech

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today iMedicalApps
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

The ethical breach surrounding the first test tube baby
3 comments

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...