Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

What’s better: Narrative medical histories or checkboxes?

David Mann, MD
Tech
February 10, 2017
207 Shares
Share
Tweet
Share

Compare the following two versions of the same medical history:

Version 1

CC: chest pain

Mr. Smith is a 57-year-old white man who comes into the office today for the first time with a complaint of chest pain. He states he has been in generally good health in the past, though he has smoked about 40 pack-years and admits to not exercising much, other than occasional games of golf. He has trouble keeping his weight down. He has been a middle-level manager for many years, but about a month ago changed jobs and took a pay cut. He says this has been quite stressful. He has changed jobs before, but states “I’m getting too old to keep doing this.” About two weeks ago he started noting some mild heaviness in his chest, lasting up to five or 10 minutes.

He attributed this at first to eating heavy meals at dinner, but now thinks it occurred after climbing stairs following meals. He took some Tums but was not sure if the pain eased from this or just from resting. These episodes of discomfort were localized to his anterior chest, without radiation or other associated symptoms at first. Over the last two weeks, he thought that they were getting a little more frequent, occurring up to twice a day. Two days before this visit, he had an episode of more intense pain that woke him up from sleep at night. This episode lasted about 15 minutes and was associated with diaphoresis. “My pillow was soaking wet.”

He woke up his wife who wanted to call 911, but he refused, though he agreed to make this appointment somewhat reluctantly. He has had no further episodes of chest pain, and feels that he is here just to satisfy his wife at this point. He doesn’t like to come to the doctor. He doesn’t know his recent lipid levels, though he says a doctor once told him to watch his cholesterol. His BP has been high occasionally in the past, but he attributes it to white coat syndrome: His BP is always normal when he uses an automatic cuff at the store, he claims. He is on no BP or lipid-lowering meds. He takes a baby aspirin “most days.” His parents are deceased: his mother had cancer, but his father died suddenly when his 40s, probably from a heart attack, he thinks.

Version 2

Mr. Smith

CC: chest pain

Age: 57 y/o Sex: M Race: Caucasian

Onset: 1 month

Frequency: > daily [X] weekly [ ] monthly [ ]

Location: Anterior chest [X] Left precordium [ ] Left arm [ ] Other [ ]

Radiation: Jaw [ ] Neck [ ] Back [ ] Left arm [ ] Right arm [ ] Other [ ]

Pattern: Stable [ ] Unstable [X] Crescendo [X] Rest [X] With exertion [X]

Duration: < 15 min [X] 15 min or more [X]

Risk factors: Tobacco [X] Family history CAD [X] HTN [?] DM [ ]

Hyperlipidemia [?]

Relief: Rest [?] Medications [?] Other [ ]

Associated symptoms: N, V [ ] Diaphoresis [X] Dizziness [ ] Other [ ]

Which is better?

Version 1 is an old-fashioned narrative medical history, the only kind of medical history that existed before the onset of electronic health record (EHR) systems. This particular one is perhaps chattier than average. It is certainly not great literature or particularly riveting, but it gets the job done. Version 2 is the kind of history that is available on EHR systems, though usually entry of a Version 1 type history is still possible albeit discouraged. With an EHR, entering a long narrative history requires either a fast, skilled physician typist or a transcriptionist — either human (frowned upon due to cost) or artificial, such as Dragon Dictation software. This latter beast requires thorough training and is frustratingly error-fraught, at least in my experience. The Version 2 example is not completely realistic. In practice, there are more checkboxes, more pull-down lists and other data entry fields than can be shown here. But you get the idea.

Version 2 seems to have a higher signal-to-noise ratio than Version 1. It’s just Version 1 boiled down to its bare essentials, stripped of unnecessary verbs, conjunctions, prepositions, and other useless syntax. It contains everything a medical coder, a medical administrator, or a computer algorithm needs to do his, her, or its job. It has taken the medical history, the patient’s story, and put it into database form.

But Version 1 is not just Version 2 embellished with a bunch of fluff. Certainly, Version 1 is more memorable than Version 2. There is a chance the physician who wrote Version 1 will remember Mr. Smith when he comes back to the office for a follow-up visit: Mr. Smith, that middle-aged fellow who was stressed out when he took a pay cut while starting a new job and started getting chest pain. Another physician meeting Mr. Smith for the first time might, after reading this history, modify his tactics in dealing with Mr. Smith. One gets the impression that Mr. Smith is skeptical of doctors and a bit of a denier. Maybe it will be necessary to spend more time with him than average to explain the need for a procedure. Maybe it would be good to tell his long-suffering wife that she did the right thing insisting that he come into the doctor. All this subtlety is lost in Version 2.

There are some cases where Version 2 might be preferable. In an emergency department, where rapidity of diagnosis and treatment is the top priority, a series of check boxes saves time and may be all that is needed to expedite a patient evaluation. But for doctors who follow patients longitudinally, Version 1 is more useful. A patient’s history is his story: it is dynamic, organic, personal and individual. No two patients’ histories are identical or interchangeable. Each history has a one-to-one correspondence with a unique person. A good narrative history is an important mnemonic aid to a physician. A computer screen full of checkboxes is no substitute.

While the Version 2 history was designed for administrators, coders, billers, regulators, insurance agents and the government, the Version 1 history was designed by doctors for doctors. We should be wary of abandoning it, despite the technical challenge of its implementation in EHR systems.

David Mann is a retired cardiac electrophysiologist and blogs at EP Studios.

Image credit: Shutterstock.com

Prev

The Physician's Bill of Rights

February 10, 2017 Kevin 4
…
Next

The last 2 patients of the day couldn't be more different

February 10, 2017 Kevin 1
…

Tagged as: Health IT

Post navigation

< Previous Post
The Physician's Bill of Rights
Next Post >
The last 2 patients of the day couldn't be more different

More by David Mann, MD

  • It’s OK if doctors can’t memorize everything

    David Mann, MD
  • Watch what you say to patients

    David Mann, MD
  • The media made a mistake reporting Carrie Fisher’s death

    David Mann, MD

Related Posts

  • Digital advances in the medical aid in dying movement

    Jennifer Lynn
  • How the COVID-19 pandemic highlights the need for social media training in medical education 

    Oscar Chen, Sera Choi, and Clara Seong
  • Does the medical profession need their version of the NRA?

    Thomas D. Guastavino, MD
  • Medical students: Here’s to becoming the best version of ourselves yet

    Sahar Rahim
  • End medical school grades

    Adam Lieber
  • What inspires this medical student

    Jamie Katuna

More in Tech

  • AI is living up to its promise as a tool for radiology

    Hoag Memorial Hospital Presbyterian
  • I’m tired of being a distracted doctor

    Shiv Rao, MD
  • AI-driven diagnostics and beyond

    Michael Kirsch, MD
  • The need for adaptability is imperative in the era of artificial intelligence

    Harvey Castro, MD, MBA
  • Harnessing the power of gamification in mental health apps

    Carter Do and Thomas Pak, MD, PhD
  • Leveraging ChatGPT’s high IQ to assist doctors

    Harvey Castro, MD, MBA
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • I’m a doctor, and I almost died during childbirth

      Bayo Curry-Winchell, MD | Physician
    • Unveiling excessive medical billing and greed

      Amol Saxena, DPM, MPH | Policy
    • Balancing efficiency and compassion [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Dying is a selfish business

      Nancie Wiseman Attwater | Conditions
    • Navigating medical decision-making: Embracing limits and growth

      Benjamin Wade Frush, MD | Physician
    • Empathy and compassion in palliative care [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • Medical gaslighting: a growing challenge in today’s medical landscape

      Tami Burdick | Conditions
    • Balancing opioid medication in chronic pain

      L. Joseph Parker, MD | Conditions
    • I want to be a doctor who can provide care for women: What states must I rule out for my medical education?

      Nandini Erodula | Education
    • Navigating the broken medical system: challenges faced by foreign medical graduates

      Anonymous | Physician
    • Mourning the silent epidemic: the physician suicide crisis and suggestions for change

      Amna Shabbir, MD | Physician
    • The essence of medicine: genuine connections in practice

      Jennifer Tillman, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • Balancing efficiency and compassion [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Reigniting after burnout: 3 physician stories

      Kim Downey, PT | Physician
    • Why patients write: stress relief, self-care, and sharing experiences

      R. Lynn Barnett | Conditions
    • Inside the grueling life of a surgery intern

      Randall S. Fong, MD | Physician
    • Misinformed claims and the offensiveness of discrediting COVID-19 vaccine development

      Angel Garcia Otano, MD | Conditions
    • Bitcoin’s role in diversified portfolios [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

View 2 Comments >

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

CME Spotlights

From MedPage Today

Latest News

  • Did Gabapentin Improve Post-COVID Olfaction?
  • Fentanyl Death Trends; Food Additives and Heart Disease
  • What If the Doctor Is Out?
  • Reduced Mortality Seen in Cancer Survivors Who Meet Exercise Guidelines
  • CDC Advisors Endorse Maternal RSV Vax to Protect Newborns

Meeting Coverage

  • Loneliness Needs to Be Treated Like Any Other Health Condition, Researcher Suggests
  • Stopping Medical Misinformation Requires Early Detection
  • AI Has an Image Problem in Healthcare, Expert Says
  • Want Better Health Outcomes? Check Out What Other Countries Do
  • ERS Roundup: Cell Transplant Boosts Lung Function in COPD Patients
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • I’m a doctor, and I almost died during childbirth

      Bayo Curry-Winchell, MD | Physician
    • Unveiling excessive medical billing and greed

      Amol Saxena, DPM, MPH | Policy
    • Balancing efficiency and compassion [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Dying is a selfish business

      Nancie Wiseman Attwater | Conditions
    • Navigating medical decision-making: Embracing limits and growth

      Benjamin Wade Frush, MD | Physician
    • Empathy and compassion in palliative care [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • Medical gaslighting: a growing challenge in today’s medical landscape

      Tami Burdick | Conditions
    • Balancing opioid medication in chronic pain

      L. Joseph Parker, MD | Conditions
    • I want to be a doctor who can provide care for women: What states must I rule out for my medical education?

      Nandini Erodula | Education
    • Navigating the broken medical system: challenges faced by foreign medical graduates

      Anonymous | Physician
    • Mourning the silent epidemic: the physician suicide crisis and suggestions for change

      Amna Shabbir, MD | Physician
    • The essence of medicine: genuine connections in practice

      Jennifer Tillman, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • Balancing efficiency and compassion [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Reigniting after burnout: 3 physician stories

      Kim Downey, PT | Physician
    • Why patients write: stress relief, self-care, and sharing experiences

      R. Lynn Barnett | Conditions
    • Inside the grueling life of a surgery intern

      Randall S. Fong, MD | Physician
    • Misinformed claims and the offensiveness of discrediting COVID-19 vaccine development

      Angel Garcia Otano, MD | Conditions
    • Bitcoin’s role in diversified portfolios [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

What’s better: Narrative medical histories or checkboxes?
2 comments

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...