Skip to content
  • About
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Book
  • Careers
  • Podcast
  • Recommended
  • Speaking
  • All
  • Physician
  • Practice
  • Policy
  • Finance
  • Conditions
  • .edu
  • Patient
  • Meds
  • Tech
  • Social
  • Video
    • All
    • Physician
    • Practice
    • Policy
    • Finance
    • Conditions
    • .edu
    • Patient
    • Meds
    • Tech
    • Social
    • Video
    • About
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Book
    • Careers
    • Podcast
    • Recommended
    • Speaking

The military is off-track when dealing with mental health problems

Allen Frances, MD
Conditions
June 4, 2014
182 Shares
Share
Tweet
Share

The headline reads, “Study: Mental illness rate higher in soldiers.”

The article goes on to offer alarming statistics:

The rate of major depression is five times as high among soldiers as civilians; intermittent explosive disorder, which results in episodes of extreme anger, is six times as high; and post-traumatic stress disorder was nearly 15 times higher than among civilians, the study found.

This would be pretty scary if true — but it isn’t. Psychiatric epidemiology is done in a way that leads to systematic bias and inflated rates of reported psychiatric disorder. And there has also been systematic carelessness in how the results are misleadingly reported by the researchers and then passed on by the media.

The fatal (unacknowledged) flaw in the epidemiological studies arises from the fact that they are so expensive to conduct. As a cost-containment measure, the thousands of interviews on which the diagnoses are based must be conducted by lay people, not by clinicians.

Having some psychiatric symptoms is part of the human condition and does not by itself indicate the presence of mental disorder. The boundary between the worried well and the psychiatrically ill is fuzzy, arbitrary, and subjective; there is no biological test. It is easy to be reliable and accurate in diagnosing severe, clear-cut disorders, but it’s impossible to be very confident about the mild ones that very likely aren’t disorders at all.

Lay interviewers cannot make this call. They have no way of judging whether the symptoms reported are severe enough, persistent enough, and pervasive enough to qualify as mental disorder. Instead, they lump anyone with symptoms among the mentally disordered.

The rates reported by psychiatric epidemiology are therefore always inflated, sometimes radically. They are no more than upper limits, not true rates. The epidemiologic interviews should be seen as no more than screening tools, not able to render a true clinical diagnosis.

It is not surprising that many soldiers have some symptoms of PTSD and sadness. But this should not be taken to mean that they qualify for a clinical diagnosis of PTSD or major depressive disorder. The epidemiologic approach is unable to confirm the clinical significance of the symptoms and to arrive at anything approaching a true rate of these diagnoses. And the claims of high rates of intermittent explosive disorder are particularly absurd.

Intermittent explosive disorder does not “result in episodes of extreme anger”; it just describes such episodes. IED is a fairly meaningless and almost totally unstudied residual category that was included carelessly in DSM only to help clinicians who needed a diagnosis for the violent people who occasionally presented for care. The fancy-sounding but essentially fake diagnosis should not lead to the stretched conclusion that all impulsivity and inappropriate violence exhibited by soldiers are signs they have a mental disorder.

What harms are there in labeling (or, rather often, mislabeling) more than a quarter of our troops as mentally ill? The harms are numerous and potentially quite dangerous:

  • Most immediately, careless overdiagnosis in epidemiological clinical studies encourages careless overdiagnosis in clinical practice. When clinicians are misled into believing that mental disorder is ubiquitous and often missed in our troops, they develop a trigger-happy, lowered threshold for making a diagnosis even when it doesn’t exist.
  • Careless diagnosis then leads to careless treatment. Rates of prescribing psychiatric drugs have skyrocketed, as has polypharmacy — that is, the use of multiple, often interacting drugs, often in recklessly high doses. Several hundred troops die each year from accidental or deliberate overdoses of prescription drugs.
  • When such a large percentage of troops gets mislabeled as mentally ill, the inaccurate and unfair stigma attaches not just to the mislabeled individuals but to the entire combat force — and it follows them into later military and civilian life. Employers used to give preference to veterans; now they worry unnecessarily about their stability when hiring them.
  • If the definition of mental illness includes many who are not really sick, the military and the VA must badly misallocate resources. Those with real mental disorders who desperately need help are neglected, while those who would do better on their own receive what may be harmful treatment and misplaced stigma.
  • A misdiagnosis of mental disorder may lead to an inappropriate provision of disability benefits. While this may benefit the individual in the short run, it often leads to real and unnecessary disabling in the long run.

Our troops deserve careful, not shotgun, diagnostic evaluation and a cautious approach to medication treatment. There should be much more attention paid to helping every returning soldier during the difficult transition out of combat zones and into ordinary military and civilian life. Soldiers should not need a mental disorder diagnosis before they can access the transitional resources that would help with this crucial adjustment.

The research reported is not just a waste of tens of millions of dollars better spent actually helping our troops; it mischaracterizes them in ways likely to lead to even more over doses of prescribed medication and even more disadvantage in the job market.

The military is far off-track in dealing with its mental health problems.

Allen Frances is a psychiatrist and professor emeritus, Duke University.  He blogs at the Huffington Post.

Prev

Savor the moments that make a life

June 4, 2014 Kevin 0
…
Next

What paying it forward in health care looks like

June 4, 2014 Kevin 0
…

Tagged as: Psychiatry

Post navigation

< Previous Post
Savor the moments that make a life
Next Post >
What paying it forward in health care looks like

More by Allen Frances, MD

  • #MeToo shows why women must learn sexual self-defense

    Allen Frances, MD
  • The problem of polypharmacy in psychiatry

    Allen Frances, MD
  • Pay primary care doctors what they’re worth

    Allen Frances, MD

More in Conditions

  • Overcoming Parkinson’s: a journey of laughter and resilience

    Cynthia Poire Mathews, FNP
  • The untold struggles patients face with resident doctors

    Denise Reich
  • Maximize sleep efficiency with stimulus control

    Pedram Navab, DO
  • The endless waves of chronic illness

    Michele Luckenbaugh
  • Surviving and thriving after life’s most difficult moments

    Rebecca Fogg, MBA
  • The surprising power of Play-Doh in pediatric care: How it’s bringing families together

    Alexander Rakowsky, MD
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • It’s time for C-suite to contract directly with physicians for part-time work

      Aaron Morgenstein, MD & Corinne Sundar Rao, MD | Physician
    • What is driving physicians to the edge of despair?

      Edward T. Creagan, MD | Physician
    • The untold struggles patients face with resident doctors

      Denise Reich | Conditions
    • The psychoanalytic hammer: lessons in listening and patient-centered care

      Greg Smith, MD | Conditions
    • Breaking free from a toxic relationship with medicine [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • Nobody wants this job. Should physicians stick around?

      Katie Klingberg, MD | Physician
    • The vital importance of climate change education in medical schools

      Helen Kim, MD | Policy
    • The fight for reproductive health: Why medication abortion matters

      Catherine Hennessey, MD | Physician
    • It’s time for C-suite to contract directly with physicians for part-time work

      Aaron Morgenstein, MD & Corinne Sundar Rao, MD | Physician
    • Resetting the doctor-patient relationship: Navigating the challenges of modern primary care

      Jeffrey H. Millstein, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • Breaking free from a toxic relationship with medicine [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Tom Brady’s legacy and the importance of personal integrity in end-of-life choices

      Kevin Haselhorst, MD | Physician
    • The hidden truths of hospital life: What doctors wish you knew

      Emily Stanford, DO | Physician
    • 10 commandments of ethical affiliate marketing for physicians

      Aaron Morgenstein, MD & Amy Bissada, DO | Finance
    • The heart of a Desi doctor: Balancing emotions and resources in oncology

      Dr. Damane Zehra | Physician
    • Safe sex for seniors: Dispelling myths and embracing safe practices [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast

Subscribe to KevinMD and never miss a story!

Get free updates delivered free to your inbox.


Find jobs at
Careers by KevinMD.com

Search thousands of physician, PA, NP, and CRNA jobs now.

Learn more

View 2 Comments >

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Pho, MD, KevinMD.com is the web’s leading platform where physicians, advanced practitioners, nurses, medical students, and patients share their insight and tell their stories.

Social

  • Like on Facebook
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Connect on Linkedin
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Instagram

CME Spotlights

From MedPage Today

Latest News

  • Journal Shows Its Commitment to Exploring AI in Medicine
  • Do Away With 'Lockout' Period in iPLEDGE, FDA Advisors Urge
  • Cluster Headache, Migraine Linked to Circadian System
  • Smaller Liver Transplant Candidates Wait Longer, Less Likely to Receive Organ
  • A 'Double Whammy' for Gastric Cancer Risk

Meeting Coverage

  • Oral Roflumilast Effective in the Treatment of Plaque Psoriasis
  • Phase III Trials 'Hit a Home Run' in Advanced Endometrial Cancer
  • Cannabis Use Common in Post-Surgery Patients on Opioid Tapering
  • Less Abuse With Extended-Release Oxycodone, Poison Center Data Suggest
  • Novel Strategies Show Winning Potential in Ovarian Cancer
  • Most Popular

  • Past Week

    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • It’s time for C-suite to contract directly with physicians for part-time work

      Aaron Morgenstein, MD & Corinne Sundar Rao, MD | Physician
    • What is driving physicians to the edge of despair?

      Edward T. Creagan, MD | Physician
    • The untold struggles patients face with resident doctors

      Denise Reich | Conditions
    • The psychoanalytic hammer: lessons in listening and patient-centered care

      Greg Smith, MD | Conditions
    • Breaking free from a toxic relationship with medicine [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
  • Past 6 Months

    • The real cause of America’s opioid crisis: Doctors are not to blame

      Richard A. Lawhern, PhD | Meds
    • Nobody wants this job. Should physicians stick around?

      Katie Klingberg, MD | Physician
    • The vital importance of climate change education in medical schools

      Helen Kim, MD | Policy
    • The fight for reproductive health: Why medication abortion matters

      Catherine Hennessey, MD | Physician
    • It’s time for C-suite to contract directly with physicians for part-time work

      Aaron Morgenstein, MD & Corinne Sundar Rao, MD | Physician
    • Resetting the doctor-patient relationship: Navigating the challenges of modern primary care

      Jeffrey H. Millstein, MD | Physician
  • Recent Posts

    • Breaking free from a toxic relationship with medicine [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast
    • Tom Brady’s legacy and the importance of personal integrity in end-of-life choices

      Kevin Haselhorst, MD | Physician
    • The hidden truths of hospital life: What doctors wish you knew

      Emily Stanford, DO | Physician
    • 10 commandments of ethical affiliate marketing for physicians

      Aaron Morgenstein, MD & Amy Bissada, DO | Finance
    • The heart of a Desi doctor: Balancing emotions and resources in oncology

      Dr. Damane Zehra | Physician
    • Safe sex for seniors: Dispelling myths and embracing safe practices [PODCAST]

      The Podcast by KevinMD | Podcast

MedPage Today Professional

An Everyday Health Property Medpage Today iMedicalApps
  • Terms of Use | Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
All Content © KevinMD, LLC
Site by Outthink Group

The military is off-track when dealing with mental health problems
2 comments

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

Loading Comments...