Cancer is a dreadful disease. Just dreadful. Make no mistake: I have tremendous respect for the awesome doctors who treat patients afflicted with it day after day. Still, paradoxically, I can’t help but notice that some of them have just as hard a time as do other doctors with caring for patients at the end of their lives. I believe a large part of their difficulty stems from the ridiculously ...
Lucy Hornstein, MD
There is no such thing as a complete physical examination
A reader writes, "Can you do a post on what procedures constitute a thorough physical, in your opinion? I haven’t had one in several years and thinking of making an appointment now. The last doctor I went to didn’t even listen to my heart or go though the motions with feeling my belly and that stuff. And of the last 3 doctors I went to, I realized they didn’t ...
Why pain cannot be a vital sign
There’s been a movement afoot for several years now to quantify pain as the so-called "Fifth Vital Sign." It all started as a well-intentioned effort to raise the level of awareness of inadequate pain control in many patients, but has gotten way out of hand.The problem is that the word "sign" has a specific meaning in ...
Challenge the constitutionality of EMTALA
Here is a letter to the editor in a recent Philadelphia Inquirer:
… In 1986, Congress passed and President Ronald Reagan signed the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor law, which requires hospitals to admit all who arrive at the emergency room and treat them without regard for their ability to pay.In essence, we had federally mandated national health care – ...
A modest proposal for a truly useful EMR
I love computers. Really, I do. Despite my oft-repeated claims about the shortcomings of electronic medical records in their current form, I do believe that information technology has the potential to be of great help to me and other physicians in providing quality care to Americans.Stop laughing. I really mean it.I do not believe, however, that IT best serves the medical needs of our patients when ...
Preventive care as a cost saving measure is a fallacy
I like reading Maggie Mahar’s Health Beat.She usually gets it, from the function of insurance to the complexities of assorted payment systems, I get the sense that she is generally rational when it comes to paying for health care. This doesn’t mean there aren’t times when she gets it wrong. Her embrace of primary care provided by nurse practitioners shows a truly spectacular ...
What’s the difference between family practice and med-peds?
I like Dr. Rob, the one with the distractible mind. And although I thoroughly agree with the stance he takes in his recent post against cholesterol screening in kids, I must take issue with his opening statement:
I have a unique vantage point when it comes to the issue universal cholesterol screening in children, when compared to most pediatricians. My unique view stems from the fact that ...
Medicine is an old profession, but not the oldest profession
Medicine is a very old profession. Ancient and honorable. Sadly, for the vast majority of recorded history, honor was pretty much all it had. The Hippocratean ideals of “first do no harm” and putting the patient first and all held special importance when medicine truly had nothing to offer. Make no mistake: up until the last two centuries, the vast majority of what passed as ...
Understanding balance billing, a primer for patients
The topic of balance billing has arisen once again, this time in this post by Movin’ Meat about the new health care insurance bill and emergency medicine.Without further explanation, “balance billing” is generally thought of as a bad thing; a way for rich doctors to squeeze even more ill-gotten gains from their poor beleaguered patients. And that’s without even realizing what it is. ...
Choose primary care and follow your heart, not your brain
Reams have been written on how medical students ought to select their field of medicine.There are even personality-type tests that ask questions about what kinds of situations you like, how you react to problems, and your working style that purport to predict for which specialty you are suited. (I came up as an oncologist or a nephrologist.)Others have opined that once you crunch the lifetime salary numbers, and then compare ...
Nurse practitioners, doctors, and the lost art of diagnosis
The topic of nurse practitioners in the context of primary care has been resurgent of late, most notably in this post by Maggie Mahar. Much of the conversation is dominated by assertions such as this:
…Nurse Practitioners have the needed training and that, in fact, doctors who have gone through the full medical school curriculum are over-qualified for a job that, today, is more about ...
Patient explanation using an analogy can trigger comprehension
I have a patient in his 60s who is riddled with metastatic lung cancer. He isn't on hospice (oncology refuses to let him out of their clutches just yet; actually, the problem is that around here Hospice won't accept patients still on palliative chemo or radiation) but is aware of what they have to offer. He and his wife have assured me that they will let me know when they ...
Why the fear of cancer undermines the new mammography guidelines
Fear is such a powerful emotion, humans will do almost anything to relieve it. The most effective way to control fear is to manage whatever it is we're afraid of. Night lights against the monsters under the bed; locks on the doors and a handgun under the pillow to fend off intruders; annual mammograms and PSAs to keep us from dying of cancer. Although all these things may relieve fear ...
