The act of doing surgery will always be honorable

In my core, I always loved doing surgery, and being surgeon to my patients. As I hope I’ve made clear in my blog, I was always amazed that I was allowed to do it, and awed at the mysterious beauty of it all. As much of a responsibility as it is, it’s also an inexplicably wondrous honor and privilege. Those words aren’t lightly written. But in a diabolical combination of being constitutionally unable to cut back, being hyper-demanding of perfection in myself and only slightly less so in those who touched my patients, mixed with a certain degree of paranoia which made me see any imperfection as an accusation, I got to a point where some sort of line was crossed. Every ring of the phone at home became a gut-shot; the emergency room was like a stalker, a heavy-breathing relentless destroyer of plans, a stealer of sleep, a wielder of a fearsome disrupter ray. Klingons, the lot of ‘em.

The cold shower of new rules, the deluge of self-fertilizing forms, the insults and veiled threats of the latest memo from some bureaucrat or other, the inverted logic of convincing some insurance cubicle-denizen that I had a legitimate reason for recommending an operation she understood not at all — I think I might have withstood all that were I better rested, had I not arranged my day for maximum continuous pressure nor added work upon work. So here’s the bouquet-toss to future surgeons: Don’t do it like I did. Give yourself a goddamn break. Good news: The system doesn’t care if you work your ass off or not. So don’t. Turns out, the world didn’t stop turning, people didn’t start dying left and right when I sheathed my scalpel.

That’s, I suppose, the corollary of my obsession: The silly sense that I was indispensable, that only I could render proper care to my patients. Don’t get me wrong: I think my judgment, my technique, and my rapport with my patients were above average (ok: way above average!) But so would they have been, had I relaxed a little. I have no doubt that rounding, as I did, three, four times a day made a difference in length of stay. But it seems I was the only one who noticed. I kept office hours four (sometimes five) days a week, wanting to be there if my patients needed to be seen, hating to have someone else see them. That meant I always had pressure to get my operations done by a certain time. I could have arranged it differently.

Making things worse, as much as I hated to be late I also hated to make others late. I almost never ran beyond my scheduled OR time. I almost always saw patients in the office exactly at the time of their appointment. I helped move patients on and off their gurneys (I’d recommend that!), cleaned up my exam rooms, whatever it took to keep things going on time. Close to crazy. I never could say no to a request to work in a woman frightened about her mammogram, instead of making her wait a few days. Couple of days? Probably would have still been ok.  The US healthcare as currently constituted is — almost as effectively as if it were deliberate — selecting against hard work and high quality, at least to the extent that it fails to recognize, encourage, or reward it. Consider it good news: Don’t kill yourself! I’m serious.

Want to have a better life? Don’t schedule yourself into your office half an hour after your last case is expected to end. Cut yourself some slack, in all things. Rounding twice is enough. Letting your partners see your patients on weekends off is ok; I saw theirs, ferchrissakes! Take all the time off you’re allowed. Avoid serving on any committee you can wangle your way out of. Get thrown off, if that’s your only option.

But be civil to the ER doc who calls at three am; and to the nurse who overlooks something, explain in non-angry terms how and why you think it could have been different. A “teaching moment,” I believe, is what they call it. Chill. Had I done so more often, I might not be blogging.

And here’s the happiest secret: There’s always one place they can’t get to you — the operating room. (They can call you, of course; but they can’t paper you, committee you, disallow you. Not while you’re there.) If you love it, that will never change; so if you love it, go for it. The act of doing surgery, distilled to its essence, the condition of being surgeon to a fellow human being – that will always be honorable and essentially untouchable, immutable. And wonderful.

It’s even conceivable that if “they” come up with meaningful ways to evaluate the quality of medical care, some sort of global, transferable, reproducible, over-arching and useful method that’s neutral and rational (pretty unlikely but not unimaginable), then the piles of paperwork, reams of rules, confabulations of committees might actually become superfluous, and a doctor will once again be allowed to be a doctor.

A physician. I like that word. It’s almost as good as surgeon.

Sid Schwab is a retired surgeon who blogs at Surgeonsblog and is the author of Cutting Remarks: Insights and Recollections of a Surgeon.

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • DoubtfulGuest

    Nice post, Dr. Schwab. I’ll always remember and appreciate the surgeons who helped me. I hope things get better for you all. This blog has been quite an eye-opener for me to read about doctors’ experiences.

  • Thomas D Guastavino

    Wow, great post. For some time now it has become clear that the least stressfull part of the entire patient care continuim, especially dealing with emergency cases, has been the actual surgery.

  • Sid Schwab

    Thanks for the comments. Kevin has been generous enough to repost some stuff from my blog, Surgeonsblog. This appeared several years ago. The blog is still active in that it gets lots of visits and I respond to comments and questions; but I haven’t added new content for quite a while.

  • Lisa

    Good advice…

    I was sad when my breast surgeon retired. I was rather surprised when I got the letter announcing his retirement, but I thought back to a discussion I had with him about surgery becoming physically hard for him as he got older, so I probably shouldn’t have been.