After a medical mistake: Honesty is the best policy

Elton John had it right: “It’s sad, so sad.  Why can’t we talk it over. Oh, it seems to me that sorry seems to be the hardest word.”  Mistakes are all to common in medicine, but can we say the “hardest word” when we’re involved?

Example 1: There’s a diagnosis of recurrent lymphoma in the ICU. The oncologist gives a phone order for cytoxan, prednisone, and vincristine. The recorder, working a double shift, mistakenly writes the vincristine daily for 5 days similar to the prednisone order. The fatal dosage is given to the patient over the ensuing days. He dies in bone marrow failure.  The oncologist met with the family and apologized.  A review was carried out.  Systems were improved.  There was no lawsuit.

Example 2: There’s a diagnosis of recurrent lymphoma in the ICU. The oncologist gives a phone order for cytoxan, prednisone, and vincristine. The recorder, working a double shift, mistakenly writes the vincristine daily for 5 days similar to the prednisone order. The fatal dosage is given to the patient over the ensuing days. He dies in bone marrow failure.

Example 3: In a radiology department, a cleaning solution rather than a dye is accidentally injected into a patient’s femoral artery leading to a painful death.

Example 4: A pharmacist fills a prescription for a patient with asthma. Instead of prednisone, the pharmacist mistakenly counts out digoxin, a pill given for heart disease. Digoxin can have severe side effects even at a dosage of one a day. The prescription is followed by the patient: take 8 a day for 3 days, 6 a day for 3 days, etc. The patient calls the MD about the symptoms of severe nausea and notes the pills look different than usual. The medication is stopped and with treatment the patient luckily survives digoxin poisoning.

Medical errors frequently hit the headlines. Also, there are a number of published articles in the medical literature, even a report to the president. Magazine articles, such as “How the American Health Care System Killed My Father,” can be both thought provoking, and provocatively accusatory. Stress and fatigue often play a role.

Medicine is not only a proud profession; it is also highly regulated. Currently doctors, nurses, pharmacists and others can face hospital sanctions, medical disciplinary boards, media scorn, and malpractice threats when they make mistakes. In most situations, a number of things have to go wrong at the same time in order for the mistake to occur. None of the above are my personal mistakes, but “I’ve been there, done that” and I guess I’m still reluctant to publish my own!

On a personal level it’s humiliating and devastating to be involved in a serious mistake. I sat down with a psychiatrist friend after a significant mistake and it helped to talk it out, but the hospital’s legal department had to be notified, affected family members met with, and eventual reports to the state dealt with (and this is in the middle of a 60+ hour week). Fortunately I was not sued, but the worry was palpable.

There’s pretty good data now, that fessing up is the best thing to do from a legal standpoint and certainly from the moral view. But believe me, it’s not easy when you’d rather hide. When one patient died after a procedure that I probably shouldn’t have attempted because he was so sick, I sat down with the family and explained the whole sequence. The son had lots of questions, but then looked reflective and said “It must be hard to be a doctor sometimes. Look it’s ok. Dad was going nowhere and he’s in a better place now.” Basically, he had let me off the hook.

On the prevention side, there’s good data from systems engineers (like Toyota and Boeing) that critical mistakes can often be prevented with good quality management and systems surveillance. All hospitals and major clinics have extensive quality control and review. The answers can be simple or complex. For example, for some recent eye surgery I had, I was asked my name and birth date three times by three separate people (even though they all knew me) — along with what operation I was having and on which side. These quality/safety techniques require constant review, updating, and reporting.

There are quality ratings of hospitals by procedures that can be reviewed. The hospital that does large numbers of, for example, carotid surgeries will almost always have better outcomes and fewer mistakes than the hospital that only does a few. It brings into question the future role of the smaller hospitals. The issue is not so much mistakes as the inability to match the experience and quality of an institution that does large number of a complex procedure.

How do we deal with all the parties involved in a mistake (the patient, family, providers, institution, legal, insurer, etc.)? Mistakes can be honestly dealt with.  A good example of this are the tort reforms successfully instituted in the state of Michigan. It is best for all involved to personally make a face to face apology! Sometimes one is forgiven, then sometimes not. But if animosity can be decreased, often a settlement can be reached after an honest admission of a mistake.. Involving the patient and/or loved ones in a case review with all present can be very powerful. It’s very hard to stay angry or want to punish someone who can look you in the eye and sincerely apologize, plus actively listening to all your concerns. There comes a point that we all recognize that we’re “only human.”

Jim deMaine is a pulmonary physician who blogs at End of Life – thoughts from an MD.

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • DoubtfulGuest

    Great post, Dr, deMaine. All I can say is Thank You.

  • Suzi Q 38

    Most physicians don’t apologize.
    The ones I have encountered would not only lie, but they would lie for other doctors as well. If you get a group like that, move on as quickly as possible to get better care and a set of physicians with better morals and integrity.

    • querywoman

      I’ve had one or two apologize. They do make make mistakes.
      But when you are really sick, and they don’t know what to do, most treat you badly and won’t even admit they don’t know.

    • SarahJ89

      I nearly died of medical malpractice. Twice. The lies and smears told about me, the alteration of my medical records, the passive-aggressive failure to correct my record (which was acknowledged verbally to be false) taught me that I can never, ever trust a doctor again.

      One of them was actually a nice person and a good doctor, But when it came to throwing me under the bus he merely pulled his punches and did not record the truth he acknowledged to me in person. I understand he was under terrific peer pressure. But in the end… I’m left holding the bag. One person did lose his job as a result, but of course it was someone far down in the food chain, not the doctor who set the chain of events into motion with his overdosing. That little weasel also tried to blame the nurses in the second hospital I ended up in. I warned them not to trust him. He’s one of those Nice Guy types adept in avoiding responsibility. The nurses thanked me for the heads up.

      But I will never trust another doctor, no matter how nice s/he may seem. I’ve learned the hard way about how they close ranks.

      • SarahJ89

        PS: I have had my former PCP make mistakes and apologize. Sincerely. We were fine after that. I don’t expect perfection, but I cannot work with global dishonestly. Dr. Weasel could have apologized and we would have been okay and I would not be left with this residue of mistrust.

        • DoubtfulGuest

          I’m really sorry for what happened to you, Sarah.

          1. Doctor nice at first…check
          2. Under-bus throwing…check
          3. Changed records…check
          4. Caving to peer pressure…check
          5. Patient holding the bag…check
          6. Lies n’smears…check
          7. Closed ranks…check

          Yes, it’s amazing how some doctors just apologize like a normal person. Maybe we can reach the others with edu-tainment:

          • SarahJ89

            OMG, Edgar Guest! Thanks for the blast from the past.

        • Suzi Q 38

          I flat out told one doctor that I didn’t trust him.
          I had to move on.

  • Margaret Fleming

    Wait a minute! What about that little phrase “double shift?” Tired people do not concentrate at top levels! There are careless people, and there are people who are exhausted and not near their best. Let’s read what some hospitals and pharmacies are doing about hours and double-checks?

Most Popular