The primary care crisis has been legislated

It was the same years ago in residency. There was both a categorical and primary care residency track. Each had their own distinctive curriculum and rotation schedule. The outpatient track did more time in the clinic, the categorical more on the hospital wards. We trained side by side. We attended many of the same lectures. And our fellowship choices matched identically. In fact, most of my colleagues from the primary care group are now cardiologists, gastroenterologists, and pulmonologists. Even then, those in training changed their opinion midstream when they realized what their professional lives would entail.

It has become vogue to blame doctors and academic institutions for the falling number of generalists. We wag our fingers at the university behemoth who takes government money and then trains super-specialized physicians. But, if you have been in education long enough, you know that the primary care push has been going on for decades. It just hasn’t been that successful. Students and young physicians, time and again, change paths when faced with the day to day work of comprehensive primary care even though it is one of the most challenging and fulfilling jobs in medicine.

Indeed, one might say we have come here by our own careful planning. We have legislated it that way.

When you create a body that advises medicare on payment structure which is made largely of specialists and proceduralists and has no interest in protecting cognitive medicine, you have legislated a primary care crisis.

When you create electronic medical records and define how to use them meaningfully, pushing physicians to waste their precious little time in the exam room on data entry, you have legislated a primary care crisis.

When you pass a colossal healthcare reform package heavy on regulation and reporting, most of which falls on the lowly family physician toiling in the overcrowded office, you have legislated a primary care crisis.

When you fight fraud and over billing of the few, by committing the many to ornate and easily deniable paperwork that everyone but the primary care doctor refuses to fill out, you have legislated a primary care crisis.

When you tell hard working and well trained physicians that they can no longer go to the hospital, create inconceivable amounts of paperwork for those who do, and then try to replace them in their offices with nurse practitioners and physician assistants, you have legislated a primary care crisis.

And lastly, when you tell them to abandon the doctor-patient dyad, and become team leaders in charge of administratively managing groups of non-physician providers and turn them into community health gurus, you have legislated a primary care crisis.

Jordan Grumet is an internal medicine physician and founder, CrisisMD.  He blogs at In My Humble Opinion.

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • Steven Reznick

    Well written. Well said. Sad but true

  • guest

    Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, and yes.

  • southerndoc1

    And every one of them enthusiastically supported by the self-hating AAFP.

  • adh1729

    All the crises have been legislated. Those in charge, don’t mean well. It is all deliberate.

    • Annie

      And once they have a crisis (of their own creation), they can take advantage of it.

      “Never Let A Crisis Go To Waste”.

      • adh1729


      • Chris


  • buzzkillerjsmith

    America simply does not want medical students in primary care. Actions speak louder than words.

  • Mengles

    Like I said before, the only people who will go into primary care are idealistic fools and those with low board scores who were at the bottom of their class and have absolutely no where else to go. The trajectory of primary care for physicians is clear. Apparently it’s so “easy”, even an NP/PA can do it.

    • IndigoBoy0

      Again you are wrong. Individuals in my class with decent board scores who could be doing other specialties from a top US school going into primary care. Just like you tell others they know nothing about residency perhaps you know nothing about who is entering primary care.

      • guest

        YOu are definitely going to be too busy if you keep posting like this…. but please sign me up in your practice!

  • morebuzzkills

    Put a stamp on this one and send it to your congressman!

    • Chris

      I actually did print out three copies last night, and I am mailing one each to my two Senators and to my Congressman. (I have found that “real” mail tends to be less likely to be ignored than email. It’s worth the price of a stamp or three to have my voice heard and my opinions noted.) I hope others will think about following your advice as well.

  • guest

    wow that is the most concise article I have ever read. Needs to be framed.

  • James E. Lewis, PhD

    For another take on some of the causes, see my Wing of Zock post for July 16, 2013 “Do Academic Medical Practice Structures Inhibit Primary Care Training and Practice?”

Most Popular