It’s time primary care doctors diagnose autism

I remember how my son’s autism diagnosis was delivered.  He was three years old.  It wasn’t a surprise really, merely a confirmation of something that I expected and feared.  He was already enrolled in speech and occupational therapy making very little progress.  He saw a developmental specialist at age two and two and half who initially believed that he was not autistic but merely delayed with sensory issues.  After we requested a more formal evaluation for autism, she referred us to the “autism specialist” in her division.

The diagnosis was “officially” given after four appointments with various “specialists” at a Children’s Hospital.  Initially my husband and I met with a psychologist who took a detailed history.  A week later we returned with our son, so the psychologist could directly observe and assess him.  He mostly screamed.  At our third appointment a trained speech therapist administered the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS), one of the few standardized tools that help physicians and psychologists diagnose autism.  Finally the fourth appointment we met with an “autism specialist” who summarized the results and confirmed his autism.  We were offered follow up in a year with either the autism specialist or her nurse practitioner.  We already had a firm plan for future therapy and education.  All we needed was a physician to sign off on the state autism scholarship form so that we could receive funding for him to attend a specialized school.  Fortunately, our health insurance paid for most of this diagnostic process, this bureaucratic, non-transparent, not especially helpful process.

By the time a child is three years old, he has had about 10 visits with his primary care doctor.  The doctor likely knows the family and the child very well.  If developmental screening revealed a delay or concern for autism (pediatricians generally screen for autism with the MCHAT at 18 and 24 months), the child has already been referred to early intervention and might be receiving additional private therapies.  The primary care provider has received the results of at least some of these evaluations and visits.  Depending on the state where the doctor practices, the early intervention team may have performed an ADOS and sent the result to the physician.

The American Academy of Pediatrics 2007 policy statement Identification and Evaluation of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders states “pediatricians must be aware of local resources that can assist in making a definitive diagnosis of, and in managing, autism spectrum disorders,” but it stops short of saying that pediatricians are the doctors that can and should make that diagnosis.  The waiting list to see a specialist can be over year depending on where the child lives.

Furthermore, many specialists do not make a diagnosis at the initial visit forcing the family to wait even longer.  Even if a diagnosis is made, the specialist does not assume the care for the child the way an oncologist would for leukemia, a gastroenterologist would for Crohn’s disease, a psychiatrist would for bipolar disorder, a pulmonologist would for cystic fibrosis, an endocrinologist would for a new onset diabetes, you get the idea.  The situation differs from that of almost every other chronic disorder, yet we know that the care of autistic children is just as complex and crucial as the other disorders mentioned.  When no doctor steps up, mothers become frustrated warriors some advocating tirelessly for evidence based therapies, others work to green vaccines and cleanse diets while most do the daily mundane heroic acts of mothering a special needs child.

Primary care providers by default end up heading the autism team.  Shouldn’t they make the diagnosis?  Do they have the time?  If we can make time for depression and complicated ADHD, we can fit an autism diagnosis into our day.  Do primary care providers have the knowledge to make a diagnosis?  Autism centers have become the “experts” in diagnosis which creates a catch 22 because these centers cannot meet demand.  Despite this, they are not reaching out to empower primary care doctors to make the diagnosis nor do they accept the diagnosis given by a different ivory tower.

A recent study conducted by Vanderbilt University with the help of the Tennessee AAP Chapter demonstrated that after a two day training, local pediatricians felt comfortable making the diagnosis of autism and agreed with specialist diagnosis 90% of the time.  Similar trainings are underway in Ohio.  I completed this training and found it helpful.  Ohio has such a back log of children who need a doctor to evaluate children with possible autism, they are trying to recruit general pediatricians to see children outside their own patient practice.  This training should be online, standardized and offered by the national AAP as an Maintenance Of Certification activity and specialists should embrace it.

Denise A. Somsak is a pediatrician.

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • Guest.

    Its time for more people to pay attention to Primary Care and give it the attention it deserves don’t ya think?!

  • Jason Simpson

    Ummmm… of course pediatricians can diagnose autism.

    Here’s the real question though: are pediatricians going to open up their schedules to squeeze in autism evaluations which are EASILY 1-1.5 hours long?

    MCHAT cant be used to diagnose autism. To give that kind of life changing diagnosis you need a comprehensive tool like ADOS, which by the way has a TON of questions with lots of nuances that non-physician parents need help to answer.

    I’ve never seen an autism diagnosis done well in a visit that is under an hour long.

    So yes, IF pediatricians are willing to open up 1 hour long appointments in their schedule, then they can easily diagnose autism.

    • denise somsak

      We do 40 minute visits for a handful of things. Most parents suspect autism long before they get a diagnosis. Breaking the news happens gradually. Between the ages of 1 to 2 years, a child has 4 well visits. That is one hour. If a parent has autism concerns, that’s most of what is discussed. Throw in a few ill visits and follow up for developmental concerns and the pediatrician already knows the child better than the developmental doctor who sees but a snapshot in time. The ADOS is now administered by early intervention teams in many states. I’m not saying pediatricians could diagnose autism all the time but at least 50% of the cases are clear cut. Those that are not can be referred. It will also help primary care docs get more knowledgeable about community and online resources to help families.

  • Sellaronda

    It is always difficult where to draw the line between what a primary care provider should be able to diagnose and when a specialist is required. Autism is common, but does require specialized testing and training to diagnose.

    In California, pediatricians are able to diagnose autism in order for a child to receive services from state agencies or from an insurance. Our local autism experts have told us it is OK to diagnose a child with autism in order for that child to receive therapy while the patient is waiting for definitive diagnosis from a specialist. A child who is later found not to have autism will not have been harmed by receiving therapies such as speech, OT, and/or ABA therapy if their symptoms indicate the need for these services. The wait for a specialist can be long, but the child should not be denied needed services in the meantime.

Most Popular