The real reason to be cautious about Z-Paks and azithromycin

The FDA issued a warning about the antibiotic azithromycin (Zithromax). The media stories have some patients terrified and some of them are calling me convinced that azithromycin is poison, a reliable agent for suicide.

What’s the hubbub about?

Azithromycin is in a family of antibiotics called macrolides, which also includes erythromycin and clarithromycin (Biaxin). Erythromycin and clarithromycin have long been known to very rarely cause fatal abnormal heart rhythms. It was thought that azithromycin didn’t have this rare side effect.

In May of last year the New England Journal of Medicine published a study that tried to confirm this. The study compared rates of sudden death while taking a course of azithromycin to the risk while taking amoxicillin, ciprofloxacin, levofloxacin, or no antibiotic. The study was not randomized. It simply matched hundreds of thousands of antibiotic prescriptions to death certificates.

The study found a tiny increased risk in patients taking azithromycin. How tiny? Compared to taking amoxicillin, taking azithromycin contributed 47 additional cardiovascular deaths per 1 million antibiotic courses. That’s one extra death per 21,276 courses. If you took 5-day azithromycin courses continuously, it would take 291 years to take that many courses of antibiotics. That’s a much slower way to die than, say, hemlock.

All patients did not have the same risk of having a fatal heart rhythm abnormality. Older patients, patients taking medications for heart rhythm abnormalities, and patients with heart disease, certain EKG abnormalities, and certain electrolyte abnormalities were at greater risk of this side effect. The patients at highest risk face one additional death every 4,100 courses of antibiotics, while those at lowest risk have one additional death every 110,000. These are very, very small risks.

So doctors should try to avoid all macrolides in high risk patients. But patients should probably forget the whole thing and avoid azithromycin for a different reason.

The reason you should avoid azithromycin is the same as the reason you should avoid all antibiotics. The risk of Clostridium difficile infection and the risk of antibiotic resistance is much greater than the miniscule risk of a fatal rhythm abnormality. That’s what should be scaring you about antibiotics. This is especially true of azithromycin because its convenient 5-day course, the Z-Pak, has become a household name and patients ask for it even when antibiotics are very unlikely to help. It is very likely that the last Z-Pak you took was for a cold, or for acute bronchitis, or for an early sinus infection, all of which resolve without antibiotics.

It would be a sad irony if we needed the irrational fear of extremely rare side effects to counter the irrational exuberance that patients have for unnecessary antibiotics. I hope instead that educated patients armed with reliable information will make good decisions.

Albert Fuchs is an internal medicine physician who blogs at his self-titled site, Albert Fuchs, MD.

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • http://profiles.google.com/mhirzel Mary L. Hirzel

    Or……… Enough doctors with the best interests of patients as their primary loyalty could insist that high dose vitamin C, IV (in the range of 100 grams except for those with the very rare G6PD deficiency polymorphism) be honestly and openly verified as an extremely safe and effective antibacterial, antiviral and antifungal.

Most Popular