The decision to prescribe testosterone replacement therapy or not

It seems like every day in the office I see at least one man concerned about testosterone deficiency.  If you look at the symptoms of testosterone deficiency most of us have one or more of these symptoms at least some of the time.  Fatigue, depression, weight gain, lack of energy, reduced sex drive, loss of physical strength, and moodiness are all described as symptoms typical of testosterone deficiency. Making the issue even more difficult it the controversy over whether testosterone levels in the lower third of the range reported as normal is in fact normal, or whether some of these men also have symptoms of testosterone deficiency.

Testosterone deficiency is also felt to be more prevalent in patients with several common medical conditions.  These include diabetes, chronic pain, metabolic syndrome, inflammatory arthritis, COPD, and advanced renal disease.  Most if not all of these problems can cause many of the symptoms also associated with testosterone deficiency.

Making the decision of whether to prescribe testosterone replacement therapy or not more vexing is that we know little about the long term effects of testosterone replacement.  We do know that some men on testosterone replacement therapy develop in increased number of red blood cells called polycythemia.  This can require cessation of testosterone therapy because polycythemia can lead to stroke and other serious complications. We don’t know if long term testosterone therapy is associated with more or less atherosclerotic heart disease, prostate enlargement or cancer.  Really we don’t know much at all about the very long term consequences.

This all is reminiscent of the wings in expert opinion on hormone replacement therapy (HRT) in women for treatment of menopause over the last couple of decades.  Consensus of opinion was to treat all women at menopause with HRT  unless there was a specific reason to avoid therapy to prevent vascular and bone disease until data showed otherwise. Now most experts recommend to try to avoid HRT except for short term treatment of severe menopausal symptoms as evidence of HRT hazards including breast cancer and  cardiovascular disease became documented.

Estimates of the prevalence of testosterone deficiency range from 2.8% to 39% in various population with the higher number being in populations with conditions like diabetes, chronic pain, etc.

In summary we are really left to decide on a case-by-case basis whether to start men on testosterone replacement therapy.  In cases where the testosterone levels are very low and the symptoms are typical I feel pretty good about starting therapy. In cases where testosterone levels are only modestly low or are at the low end of normal but symptoms are present it is much less clear when therapy is indicated.  I often feel like my arm is being twisted by some men desperate for some help with their symptoms, and we have to decide on the risk-benefit balance best for them.

When therapy is indicated the route of administration of testosterone, transdermal testosterone as a gel or patch vs. intramuscular (IM) injection is the next decision.  A big factor in making this decision is the high cost of all the branded transdermal products ($330 per month for Androgel on, others similar) which have the advantage of not requiring IM injections and steadier daily dosing. The much less expensive IM shots with the discomfort and risk of IM administration and the peaks and troughs of testosterone levels are often used to reduce cost of therapy.

I look forward to more research on the long term safety, benefits and risks of testosterone deficiency therapy.  I’m confident there is a lot we don’t know.  I suspect the answers will be slow in coming and surprising whatever they show.  Stay tuned but don’t hold your breath.  This research is not likely to be funded by Big Pharma, and I don’t know of any current long term not-for-profit studies underway.

Edward Pullen is a family physician who blogs at

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • J Foley

    Repeat measurements are important to confirm initial values. Phlebotomy
    should be conducted between 7:00-10:00 AM. Full testosterone panels with
    total testosterone, free testosterone, SHBG, LH can also be useful in
    sorting through primary hypogonadism versus late onset hypogonadism
    (LOH) but assays for testosterone vary from lab to lab. Free
    testosterone is usually a calculated value so is subject to error.
    Equilibrium dialysis is the most reliable to measure Free testoserone
    but is not widely available- translation: expensive. Depending on LH
    values, prolactin measurements may uncover pathology although quite
    uncommon. A good link for more information is: Also, don’t
    overlook the indication to screen for osteopenia, etc with a DEXA scan
    in bona fide cases of hypogonadism.

    If I’m on the fence about initiating treatment and I’m not sold on the
    patient’s symptom complex, I will advise them that hypogonadism is
    similar to diabetes in that it can be managed with lifelong replacement
    therapy, but not cured. So, we both have to agree to go down that road
    especially because of the cost. I also set expectations that reversal of
    symptoms may not be complete and may take months since most of these
    patients became hypogonadal over years not weeks.

  • StephenModesto

    A thought provoking
    article. I am sitting silently at the screen as I add a comment. It is difficult
    to separate the cosmetics of consumer driven medical interventions with
    relevant adjunctive care. Does `deficiency’ actualize a `disease’ in a medical
    model? The ED meds certainly have helped the obvious symptom of age related
    changes; there certainly has been a decrease in the Asiatic mystiques of
    killing rhinoceros, tigers, bears for their sympathetic body parts. The
    Androgel TV commercials are selling improved body designed cars. No, they do
    not include that the daily cost is $10 a day. The profession of medicine has
    move from the understanding of basic body systems to the complex. Endocrinology
    is poorly understood primarily because the interdependent variables of the
    psychoneurology within the functioning of mind inside the structural functions
    of the brain are poorly understood. Yes, quality of life is important as people
    in general are enabled to extend the quantity of life. A perspective of a
    contemplative view of Holism in living life is really more than just avoiding
    processed preserved foods….but the marketed consumers do enjoy those TV

  • Robert J DuCharme

    Dr. Pullen, what is considered low??? I was actually on Andro Gel 1.0% for 90 days and my total testosterone actually went down from 250 to 202! I am very curious….

Most Popular