Planned Parenthood can’t accept Medicaid in Texas: Why we should care

She knew she was supposed to be careful about getting pregnant, although truthfully she didn’t think it could happen because of her blood pressure and kidney problems. The nurses at the county clinic started her on the pill, but her blood pressure went all crazy. They asked her to come back on a Wednesday night when the doctor was there. The doctor asked lots of questions and spent a lot of time with her. It was nice to see a doctor care so much.

The Wednesday night clinic was where the nurses sent you when they needed the doctor’s help. It took two buses to get to that clinic and she had to wait an hour after it closed for her boyfriend to get off of work so he could pick her up, but she went because the nurses were so insistent.

The doctor (so young, she looked right out of medical school) asked her to stop the pill, something about the estrogen. The doctor tried to talk her into an IUD. Said it was the safest thing. But it sounded scary and some ladies at church said it caused abortion, so she wasn’t so sure about that.

Eventually she agreed to the Depo-Provera shot. Made her bleed all over the place for a while, but after a couple of shots she stopped getting her period altogether so that was okay.

Her boyfriend got a job in a new city, so they moved. She didn’t have a car, and even if she did she couldn’t afford the gas money to go back to the county clinic where she used to get her Depo shot. The nurses there were very nice and she was sure they would have looked the other way seeing she now lived in a different county. But they told her about Planned Parenthood. She could get her Depo there. She was so excited when she realized it was only six blocks from her apartment.

When she called to make an appointment for her Pap and Depo she was told Planned Parenthood couldn’t accept her Medicaid. Wasn’t allowed to accept Medicaid. Some law. “But I don’t want an abortion,” she said.

“Doesn’t matter,’ the receptionist said. “The government of Texas refuses to let any state tax dollars go to Planned Parenthood. You’ll have to pay for the visit and your Depo, but we do have a way to reduce the price for you.”

Even then it was a lot of money. More than she had right now. She called several doctors, but no one accepted Medicaid. “Doesn’t pay enough to cover our expenses,” they said.

And then one thing sort of led to another. She got a job at the Wal-Mart, but only part-time, so no health benefits. She needed the money to pay for her blood pressure pill. And food. Her boyfriend’s job wasn’t as many hours as they’d hoped. She bought condoms when she had the money, but stopped after a while. Deep down she had always thought she couldn’t get pregnant. The doctor at the county clinic told her not to count on it. The doctor said she had delivered many women who never believed they could get pregnant.

The sound of the doctors at her door brought her back to the here and now. She went to the emergency room the night before with the worst headache she had ever had. The look on the emergency doctor’s face when he saw her blood pressure was almost comical. And the swelling, he’d wanted to know how long it had been that bad.

He told her she was probably six months along. That she had something called preeclampsia. Her kidneys couldn’t handle the stress of being pregnant. When they got her to labor and delivery the OB said she needed to have the baby. As soon as possible. It didn’t matter that she was so early. She could have a stroke and her kidneys might fail. They told her that her baby had a 60-70% chance of surviving.

Her headache was a little better. The medication to bring down her blood pressure helped. The contractions hurt, but they weren’t that bad. She listened closely to the doctors at the door. They were talking about her ultrasound. She thought the lady who was doing the scan had taken a long time. She’d even called someone over to look at the screen. Something about not enough fluid so it was hard to see.

Only one doctor came in. A lady. She walked like she was in charge. She pulled up a chair. Her face looked a lot softer up close. “Your ultrasound has some findings and I need to talk with you about them. We know the fluid is low. We knew that from the initial scan we did last night. We talked about that this morning. But this latest ultrasound is more detailed and gives us more information. Your baby is smaller than expected. That could be from your blood pressure, but there is something else. Some problems with the bones in the skull. You were taking a blood pressure medication and it looks as if there are some birth defects.” The doctor paused.

“What does that mean for my baby?” She thought it sounded odd to say those words, my baby, out loud. A baby she didn’t even know she was carrying until yesterday. A baby she thought she could never have.

And that’s when she started to cry.

Jennifer Gunter is an obstetrician-gynecologist and author of The Preemie Primer. She blogs at her self-titled site, Dr. Jen Gunter.

email

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1349019007 Jared A. Chambers

    This is what we call an anecdote.  No matter what belief you hold, no matter how at odds with the facts at large, piles of statistics, laboriously extracted empirical data, you can still find an anecdote to make your case.  And without the harsh light of critical reasoning, that seems pretty impressive.  Various charlitans, magicians, sooth-sayers, etc. have done it for years.  But it doesn’t mean anything.

    Planned Parenthood isn’t so much a health organization as a political one, and government dollars should not go to political advocacy groups.  It’s an incestuous relationship.  Try thinking about this.  The NRA, in addition to its noted Second Amendment lobbying efforts, also funds many educational programs centered around gun safety for kids… even (maybe especially) for kids who don’t grow up in households with guns, to teach them not to handle them and to alert adults.  So, if the Federal Government agreed to fund these programs, but not the lobbying, you’d be okay with that, right?  Of course you wouldn’t, because every dollar the NRA didn’t have to spend out of its general fund for this program could then go to lobbying!

    We all have our biases, I actually support reproductive choice and gun rights, but having an ounce of reasoning ability, I can tell you government funding political causes, whether you agree with the cause or not, is a horrible idea….  No matter how many sad anecdotes you can find to the contrary.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2LRZNHDZS6DU45WQ567LPQ7CMI ninguem

      One thing I’ve learned long ago in medicine is you never say “always” or “never”, or you are guaranteed to eat your words, sooner or later.

      A tragic story. Anyone who says this sort of thing “never” happens in….Canada, the UK, France, the healthcare paradise du jour, has not done the simple search to find similar problems all over the planet. The Canadians themselves have their own organizations, their own research, into the gaps in healthcare within their own system. Do a simple search for Pity’s sake.

      Heck, France’s own “Doctors Without Borders” has run clinics WITHIN FRANCE ITSELF because of access problems in their own country.

      It’s not helpful to say such things “never” happen, as it just means the person saying that, has not bothered to look. It happens. It’s fair to consider whether it happens more, or less, frequently, how to fix the problem, what it would cost to fix the problem, etc.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/IRZ2PVW4NRT7GEY3JL5FVXFZ7Q Val

    Anecdotal or not this kind of thing does happen there, and it’s appalling. We have our problems in Canada, but not this.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1349019007 Jared A. Chambers

    No, you just would have died waiting there.  Again, finding an appaling abberancy is not evidence, especially if acting on that anecdote would lead to bigger and more problems.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/IRZ2PVW4NRT7GEY3JL5FVXFZ7Q Val

    Your comparison is not valid… very unfortunate, unintentional oversight vs political or religious interference. I’m not going to continue this as there is obviously no way we will agree… esp. given that you actually seem to be equating women’s health with gun laws… Planned Parenthood with the NRA. Ludicrous.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1349019007 Jared A. Chambers

    Two political lobbyist organizations?  Seems pretty valid unless, again, you’re willing to ignore hard evidence in light of a singular sensational, if misleading, story.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2LRZNHDZS6DU45WQ567LPQ7CMI ninguem

       What the story really says, is it sucks to be poor. I agree. If you’re poor in ANY country, regardless of the funding mechanism for healthcare, it will be more difficult to access healthcare, for all the usual reasons. Canada, France, UK, etc., they all say the same thing in their own internal studies.

      The problem is, as always, how to make things better for the poor, without making EVERYONE poor.

      • Anonymous

        Of all the so-called first world countries, being poor in America is the worst country to be poor in. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1546088532 George Wilson

    Politics is deeply woven into this issue.  The current administration has cut off funding to Texas for low income women’s health because Texas does not allow PP to participate.  In light of this anecdote, the woman would never have received any depo provera shots.  
    http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/obama-admin-cuts-birth-control-funding-low-income-women-texas_633899.html

  • Anonymous

    Poor girl. She must’ve been one of the unlucky ones…you know, the ones walking around with an iPhone 3gs instead of 4… :/

    • http://www.facebook.com/cunningham.lizzy Elizabeth Diop

      this comment is judgmental.  and not helpful.

  • Sarah Wells

    Planned P.  can’t accept medicaid, but it can accept donations,  and donations directed  for patients who cannot pay.  PP can still provide care for medicaid qualified at no charge if it chooses to make that a mission of its care.   

    This woman wasn’t too poor or too stupid to understand that pregnancy could make her sick or kill her (and/or the baby).   If PP was unable to convince her that her conditions did not preclude pregnancy,  just a safe pregnancy,  some fault lies with one or the other.  

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2LRZNHDZS6DU45WQ567LPQ7CMI ninguem

       From George Wilson’s link to the Weekly Standard
      http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/obama-admin-cuts-birth-control-funding-low-income-women-texas_633899.html
      sounds like the Obama Administration cut off funding for birth control, because Texas stopped funding to Planned Parenthood over abortion.

      A convoluted story, not sure if I’m getting the whole scoop.

    • Anonymous

      Hmmm. And that means… that PP Is more concerned about getting reimbursed than they are about providing care. Why should PP not be taken to task for turning the girl down and denying her services? They talk a good talk about providing services to the poor and minorities, but when it comes down to it, it’s “show me the money.”

  • Anonymous

    And the moral of the story is…. what? It appears to be that the cause of this tragedy is the defunding of Planned Parenthood. If only PP could take Medicaid! Those evil people who passed this law!

    I agree, it IS a tragedy. A terrible thing. And maybe it wouldn’t have happened if PP could take Medicaid. But then again, the lack of funding for PP did not cause her to be complacent when the Depo ran out. Or to  neglect her blood pressure. Or to not pay attention to her body when she became pregnant. These reflect a deeper crisis that is unrelated to funding of PP and which no government health program will solve. The crisis is not one of health care or free birth control, but of self-respect. No free health services or products can make someone care about herself enough to take care of herself. That has to come from within. And we can fund PP up the wazoo and it won’t make a difference in that regard.

    • Anonymous

      exactly. i just have trouble believing that she couldn’t afford condoms after she and her boyfriend are working. At that point, there are bigger issues than if PP accepted medicaid. 

  • AuthenticBioethics

    Right here on KevinMD there’s a post about the very phenomenon: You can give someone all the services and products they need, and they STILL won’t take care of themselves. This post here is about pregnancy, and the other post is about obesity, but the principle is the same. Health care begins with the patient taking care of herself, and that has to come from within. http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2012/03/problem-obesity-counseling.html

  • Anonymous

    I guess she didn’t hear the “ladies at church” tell her to cross her legs…

    • http://twitter.com/SuzyWier Suzy Wier

      I remain amazed that in 2012 it is still the woman’s responsibility to say no.  I think they have scientific evidence proving that there must be a male involved in the process.  The prevailing attitudes about woman that become pregnant are disturbing.

  • Sapphire Storm

    It is quite appalling the judgments I found in many of these replies. I wonder how many of you have been poor, perhaps uneducated, perhaps unable to get to your doctor’s office? Is this anecdotal? I seriously doubt it. I think it is completely common. In order for an individual to take good care of her (or him) self, they need to be understood; the roots of noncompliance need to be teased apart. I wonder if this woman was told about any possible birth defects from her medicine? There are just too many questions here and condescending judgments are disgusting.
    Secondly, to not allow payments to Planned Parenthood is pretty much a war against the poor; and it will cost more in the long run, in lives and money as most wars do.

    You know why poorer people and obese people and old people don’t go to the doctor?  It is this horrible judgmental attitude (and not having resources to get there)

    • Anonymous

      yes well, the article says that PP turned her away because she couldn’t pay. So the question is, is PP for the poor or not? And stop the hyperbole and unfair accusations: If I object to funding PP there could be a million reasons ordered to providing BETTER care for the poor for my objection. PP is just one way of getting medicals services to poor people, not the only way, and not the best way. They are in it for the money, not to help poor people. Otherwise, they’d help poor people instead of turning them away, right?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SXLE3YXLSQV54YZYNNSQJDMNO4 WonderWitch, Psychedelic Druid

    Everyone here who is being judgemental needs to work for minimum wage or close to it and not have a car for a few months. It would really change your way of thinking. I might have died 20 years ago had I not been able to get free medical care for STROKE-LEVEL high blood pressure. I paid the clinic what I owed them over time BTW. Texas has NO business denying PP medicaid–isn’t that a Federal program ?

    • Anonymous

      Medicaid is administered by the states.

  • Anonymous

    Ye without sin cast the first stone. If you haven’t been a poor woman in this living from hand to mouth and trying to stay healthy, let alone not get pregnant, then shut up. Time for women’s healthcare to be between them and their physicians and if Medicaid can provide healthcare for men than it can for women without nit picking about what they will pay for. All you super conservatives who hate government so much why do you want your intrusive government in our bedrooms and our physician’s exam rooms? You are hypocrites.

  • Anonymous

    Regardless of your politics and your stance on PP/abortion/party affiliation the fact remains that when this impaired infant is born and if it lives even for a while with anencephaly, cerebral anoxia, or any other host of anomalies: you and I are going to pay for its care because its parents cannot.  THAT is the take home on this particularly tragic tale which is more common than you realize.  I urge you to visit ANY ‘pediatric long term care facility’ to view some of these piteous youngsters, many of whom can and will live many years when their O2 and nutrition needs are met (yes, on Medicaid!)  Tube feedings, decubiti, OT, ST, PT (even for those in persistent vegetative states) are not uncommon.  Often, these unfortunates get no visitors because parents have either split up, moved or taken the advice of their friends/social workers/relatives and ‘put the past behind them’ or may have other, healthy children.  These warehouses are often called ‘children’s rehab hospitals’ and many of the staff who work there are some of the most caring in the industry, but those professionals are paid to maintain these tragic little lives who never had a chance at living, breathing on their own, walking, hearing, talking or eating
    .Now, make your decision about what this mother (real or imagined) will do with her multiply handicapped preemie baby who WILL be vigorously resucitated in the delivery room I assure you,  and whose hundreds of thousands of dollars in NICU bills will have to be written off as the infant is eventually transferred from the acute care hospital to the ‘pediatric rehab’ in about six to eight months, with a tracheostomy and gastrotomy tube with NO HOPE of ever living a meaningful existanceTHINK about the real cost of such a scenario in the aftermath;  NOT just the hyperbole.  

Trending