Why do people decide to become doctors anyway?

An excerpt from This Won’t Hurt A Bit (and other white lies): My Education in Medicine and Motherhood. Copyright © 2011 by Michelle Au. Published by Grand Central Publishing.

Why do people decide to become doctors anyway?Let’s look at this first purely from the perspective of personal investment and expectation. To practice medicine, first, you have to go to medical school. That’s four years right there. Then, there’s residency, which adds anywhere between three and seven years to the deal. After that, there may be a fellowship, sometimes two fellowships, because really, at that point, what’s another year or two (or six)? So basically, from the moment you start into medical school to the moment you finish your training, you’re looking at a minimum of seven years—for most people it’s closer to ten—before you’re even close to being considered a “real” doctor.

And these are not fun, carefree years—certainly not the way most people spend their twenties, at least if the producers of MTV or beer advertisers are to be believed. You spend these fetal-doctor years indoors under fluorescent lighting, nose pressed into books filled with inscrutable diagrams and endless acronyms, while everyone in the world, including some of your patients, appears to be having more fun than you. These are years spent doing a whole lot of work for little or no money, ignominious tasks relegated to those contractually obligated to never complain. These are years of thousands of lost hours spent at the hospital instead of with your friends and family, who always seem to be wondering where you are and why you’re still there and when, if ever, you’ll be coming home. These are years spent defying all common sense about circadian rhythms and the regenerative powers of rest, largely awake and caffeinated to an almost toxic degree. And—this last part is the real kicker—these are years after which you will end up in hundreds and thousands of dollars of debt, all for the experience of what amounts to hard time in a well-intentioned Soviet gulag. I repeat: not fun.

It was true that I wanted to be a doctor, but there were other things I wanted to be at the same time. Like many people I knew, I imagined that by the time I was thirty (OK, maybe thirty-five), I would be in a committed relationship with someone that I loved, or at least sort of liked. Maybe I would be married. Perhaps I would have kids, presented the time and the opportunity and provided that the corrosive powers of time did not rob me completely of my reproductive potential by the time I was ready for the responsibility. Barring that, maybe I would have a dog. Or at least a fish.

But then I would go into the hospital on my General Surgery rotation and see a bunch of bitter, tired men in their thirties, still years away from their first paying job, all either single or divorced or in some way separated from their spouses, and their sole message of wisdom to impart to their medical students was, Dude, whatever you decide to do with your life, don’t do this.

But despite it all, despite the complete disconnect between the life of medicine as we saw it and the real life we envisioned for ourselves, many of us decided to become doctors anyway. Why? I believe that for most people, there’s a spectrum of reasons.

First and hopefully underlying all the other reasons, there’s probably the pure and honest desire to want to do good in life. I want to help people. Put aside the fact that many jobs are expressly designed to help people—the barista helps people by getting them their coffee, the dry cleaner helps people by pressing their shirts, the street mime helps people by making them realize that no matter how terrible they think their lives are, at least they’re not street mimes—and you have what seems like a pretty good blanket answer to throw out there at interviews and family functions, provided that there are absolutely no follow-up questions. (Unfortunately, there always are.)

Perhaps some people have a special facility for applied science. That seems reasonable enough. There’s so much Biology and Chemistry and Physics and Physiology in medicine that in medical school, we spend two straight years studying nothing else. That said, there are plenty of people who are gifted in Biology and Chemistry and Physics who have no business being anywhere near other human beings, and would perhaps better serve the world in the back of a computer lab, writing Battlestar Galactica fan fiction and engaging in heated online arguments with others doing the same.

Maybe you have had a Medical Experience, and as a result of your Medical Experience you had an epiphany and decided that you would like to become a doctor yourself. A personal incident of illness or injury, time spent caring for a sick parent, a particularly moving episode of ER circa The Clooney Years—this overall seems like a valid precursor to a career in medicine. (Well, maybe not the ER thing.) You have had an encounter in the field and have some true and earnest desire to either perpetuate the good that you have witnessed or to expose and eradicate the wrongs. However, if this were the main reason that people decided to become doctors, medical schools would be filled with classes of students with dead parents and crippled siblings, and at least from my experience, this is not overwhelmingly the case.

There are, however, plenty of people in medical school who have a doctor in the family. Usually one parent, sometimes both. Coming from a medical dynasty can have its pluses and minuses—on one hand, these people are usually down-to-earth and diligent, as they are going into the family business and know both what to expect and what is expected of them. On the other hand, some of them act like by virtue of birthright, they are doctors already, and the actual process of medical training is just an unfortunate technicality.

Sometimes people become doctors because it’s a well-respected field with which most people have a passing familiarity. The window dressings of medi•cine are well known to any layman with a television—the long white coats, the stethoscopes slung casually around the neck in battle-ready position, the Hippocratic oath to “first, do no harm.”

The doctor is an icon, instantly recognizable. Children tell parents they want to become doctors the same way they say they want to be teachers or scientists or astronauts, because they know what doctors are, and what they do, and because expressing an interest in medicine makes parents instantly happy. (Maybe there are some children who express the desire to be hedge fund managers when they grow up, but those children should probably be checked periodically for clustered sixes in the hairline.) Early on in medical school, some guys in my class used to go out to bars wearing their medical school IDs with the notion that it would help them pick up women. While their technique was dubious, they perhaps more than any of us understood the power and respect of the medical degree. And the thrill that a new intern feels the first time she is referred to as “Doctor” is universal and undeniable, the excitement of finally being accepted into an exclusive pantheon, something like being knighted.

And let’s not beat around the bush, sometimes people decide to become doctors because of the money. No one talks about it, but risking excommunication, I’m telling you. It’s hardly a “get rich quick” scheme, but for most of us, it is at least a “get moderately well-off slow” scheme. While I certainly don’t think that you should go into medicine solely for the money (there are much easier ways to earn money—growing and selling your hair for high-end wigs comes to mind), I also don’t think it’s wrong to consider a career in medicine for its practical benefits. A stable career with good earning potential—isn’t that what most people look for? But no, we don’t speak of such earthly concerns, especially not when the popular notion of The Good Doctor imagines him subsisting solely on handshakes and goodwill. Though no one ever seems to want to talk about the details, I can confidently tell you that while income varies across specialties and geography, overall, doctors make a lot of money.

So there is altruism. There is the academic interest. There are societal influences and personal influences and there is of course the matter of money. Students going into medicine probably cycle through most if not all of these reasons at some point in their decision process, sometimes multiple times in one day. It is easier, for example, to be altruistic at 9:00 a.m. than at 2:00 a.m. Motivations also may change as an individual matures, and the rosy idealism of the twenty-two-year-old first-year med student may eventually give way to the real-world considerations of a married father of two trying to support a young family on a single salary. I can’t understand everyone’s reasons or the factors that temper their decisions, but in most cases it boils down to this: we want to become good doctors because we want to be able to make a positive and meaningful difference in the lives of people when they need help the most. And for this privilege, we’re willing to deal with the rest of it.

But I will tell you one thing I know for certain. No one decides that they want to be a doctor because they want to be a scutmonkey.

So what, the civilians want to know, is a scutmonkey?

There are versions of scutmonkeys in most professions. The entertainment business has its production assistants, the mob has its “button men,” and in medicine, we have our scutmonkeys—the hungry, scrabbling masses charged to do the jobs no one else wants. Sometimes these jobs are distasteful, almost always these jobs are menial, and not infrequently, these jobs are just flat-out boring, which is probably why SCUT is perhaps best understood as an acronym one of my residents passed on to me: “Sub-Cerebral Use of Time.” And yet all of us in medicine, from the silver-haired senior attending on down, have at one time or another been scutmonkeys.

Luckily, being a scutmonkey is a temporary condition. It starts with medical school under the guise of education, fully manifests during residency and fellowship, when we are technically paid to get scutted out (and why senior doctors feel free to assign scutwork with much less guilt), and resolves itself fully upon completion of training. Despite the painful and often protracted nature of the scutmonkey years, senior doctors often seem to have a degree of retrograde amnesia when it comes to the travails it took to get them there. Sure, they have their stock of old war stories, which are pulled out, dusted off, and, like baby pictures, passed around the assembled audience, where they are duly admired or subversively one-upped. But overall, doctors finished with their training see themselves plucked from the mire and deposited into an altogether more agreeable lifestyle, not unlike Willis and Arnold on Diff’rent Strokes, though perhaps with even less interest in looking back. And really, it doesn’t take long to forget the old neighborhood. “Honestly, things are completely different now,” one young attending once told me. “It’s so much better. You just wait and see. I can hardly remember what it was like to be a resident anymore. I honestly can’t believe I used to live like that.” She had graduated from her Pediatrics residency all of six months earlier.

Nobody goes into medicine to be a scutmonkey, but almost all of us look forward to what comes after. The day when, we envision, we will be able to practice medicine the way we want. The day when we will be able to decide what and when and how things will be done for our own patients during the day, and yet have enough freedom to have lives outside of the hospital as well. When we will be valued for our years of advanced education, for our clinical expertise, for our judgment, not just for the decerebrate ability to write down lab values and page EKG technicians and push stretchers from Point A to Point B at 3:00 a.m. The day when we will have scores of little scutmonkeys of our own to dispatch on a whim, to take care of the things that we will be too important to do.

Michelle Au is an anesthesiologist and author of This Won’t Hurt A Bit (and other white lies): My Education in Medicine and Motherhood.


Submit a guest post and be heard on social media’s leading physician voice.

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • Dr Chris

    Actually, the scut doesn’t stop.
    And the reason that people avoid primary care is that it’s very scut intensive.
    There are prior auths, med compliance forms, (your patient hasn’t refilled her meds on time) diabetes compliance forms, (did you send your patient to the dentist,the opthamologist. Yes, I did. I did not however personally drive them)
    There are many many prescriptions, requiring rewrites of all of them when the patient changes health plans.On line, it actually take much longer-you can simply sign the fax for the script or the five steps at least online-the med and dose, the instructions. Did you mean it? DId you really mean it? Did you really means to send it to the local pharmacy? If there are 6 meds, and you get interrupted, you may think you did the script, but no, you have to start all over again. But you will get the same fax again, because the pharmacy didn’t check online.
    Calls from families of frail patients. One’s choice is more staff and more overhead, or doing it yourself-more time. The call is different, but it’s for all your patients, and your partners, not the ones on your in hospital panel.
    I love what I do, but it’s very scut intensive.

    • http://fertilityfile.com IVF-MD

      Thanks for sharing, Dr. Chris. I often gripe about the unnecessary scut that I have to deal with but in comparison, I’ll just shut up and say that my heart goes out to you and your colleagues. You are very strong-willed to be able to keep a good attitude despite having all that unnecessary nonsense thrust upon you. Ugh.

  • Edward Chow

    I love her blog!

  • http://onsurg.com/about Chris Porter MD

    Great piece Dr Au! But you missed one motivation. I went into medicine (general surgery) so I could hit the overhead call light when the flight attendant asked if there was a doctor on board. When the moment finally came, I hit that button like the fastest brother Richard Dawson ever saw. Then I immediately thought: Man, I hope the emergency is something I know, like breast cancer.

  • Zoya

    Quiiiiiite frankly sometimes I ask myself the very same question — why the hell did I ever decide this was a good idea?
    But frankly… though I have talents elsewhere that come far more easily to me (music, computers, other assorted things) I can’t imagine myself doing anything else with my life but being a doctor. Now the trick is figuring out how to be a doctor… and a mother, and a musician, and all those other things. ;)

  • Doc99

    This post somehow reminds me of DeNiro’s soliloquy about Navy Divers in “Men of Honor” -

    The Navy Diver is not a fighting man, he is a salvage expert. If it is lost underwater, he finds it. If it’s sunk, he brings it up. If it’s in the way, he moves it. If he’s lucky, he will die young, 200 feet beneath the waves, for that is the closest he’ll ever get to being a hero. Hell, I don’t know why anybody’d want to be a Navy diver.


  • http://theunderweardrawer.blogspot.com/ Michelle Au

    @Dr. Chris: I think you are absolutely right, and I saw that a lot before I switched from Pediatrics to Anesthesia. Even as an attending in Peds, you are on the phone talking to insurance companies and faxing things to the pharmacy. I once joked that if I had a secretary to take care of all my purely clerical duties, it would cut my work in half. Only it wasn’t a joke.

    @Edward Chow: Thanks!

    @Chris Porter MD: Oh man, I live in dread of the overhead airplane call, mostly because I know they have next to no meds or equipment on airplanes. That fear of knowing what to do and having no tools with which to work! It’s pen-and-straw trache time…

  • dm, pgy1

    Also a big fan of Dr. Au — I can’t wait until her book comes out. And lol at Chris Porter’s anecdote

  • http://theunderweardrawer.blogspot.com/ Michelle Au

    @Zoya: Agreed. It’s not so much that being a doctor is that hard, or that being a parent is hard, or having a life outside of work is that hard. It’s when you try to do all those things together that things get kind of difficult!

    dm, pgy1: Wait no more, the book is shipping out now! Amazon and B&N started shipping out late last week! :)

  • http://masterofmedicine.com Jobin Martin

    I think being a doctor has lot of benefits,the satisfaction derived from saving lives or having long conversations with people who just love to have someone listen to their woes is just a couple of those. A doctor always get treated well, even the police won’t touch you unless it is absolutely necessary.

  • http://www.doreenorion.com Queen of the Road

    @Jobin Martin: You are right about the police. I was stopped once in residency for speeding while wearing a Halloween costume that looked particularly, shall we say, unprofessional. It was a few days before Halloween and the officer asked if I had any ID on me with “MD” on it. I showed him a credit card.

  • http://blaggieplaggie.blogspot.com Yolanda (Blaggie Plaggie: Babblings of a Mommy Doctor)

    Becoming a doctor is no easy task. I think most people do recognize that, although there is a lot of inflated idealism going into the career.
    But when all is said and done, I still think being a doctor has benefits that far outweigh the lows. I am thankful for my profession and the opportunities that come with it. I have my days of complaining, but I’m constantly reminded through both patients and people in my life that I have little to complain about in comparison.
    How much life sucks as a doctor does depend ultimately on the life choices one makes. And those choices ultimately reflect your priorities and what matters to you most. So in the end, I do challenge the notion that we have any right to complain about the decisions we make regarding what kind of doctor to become, what kind of environment we work in, and how much money we aspire to make in order to keep up the lifestyle we’ve chosen. I know patients would much prefer doctors who are happy rather than bitter.
    As for scut, that is unfortunately the reality of any profession. It’s not relevant to just residency. Almost everybody is somebody’s scut monkey to a certain degree, so I’ll take the scut of medical work over the scut of many other jobs out there. And personally, even the scut of medical work is still less frustrating than the scut of raising kids.

    • http://medschoolodyssey.wordpress.com Med School Odyssey

      The difference between scut during medical training and the scut in normal jobs is that it usually isn’t 80 hours a week of it, every week without end.

  • DeelyStan

    I don’t think the confusion or concern is strictly a gender thing. I (like) medicine……but I (love) my wife and children. There is not a day that goes by that doesn’t find me wishing I could pick them up from school, be there when the play started, show up when the game started (not the fifth inning). I reckon these are consequences I knew when my acceptance letter came in the mail, but the ramifications of these choices don’t make the decision any better.

    The other facet of medicine that physicians need to let go of (which is a constant struggle) is the the “things will be so much better when” syndrome. It starts with acceptance to medical school, then looking onward to clinical rotations, then graduation, then choice of specialty, then the boards then finishing training, then student loans……once one hurdle is crossed, there is a transient, but fleeting moment of happiness, then the realization of the time and energy needed for the the next phase. Medicine does not lend itself to many instances of “joy in the journey.” It does however cause deep reflection on what really matters in life….when you glance up and see that picture of you your baby boy or girl (or perhaps your wedding photo) and wonder what happened to the last decade of your life.

Most Popular