Nurses are underappreciated but key to patient care

“No man, not even a doctor, ever gives any other definition of what a nurse should be than this — ‘devoted and obedient.’ This definition would do just as well for a porter. It might even do for a horse. It would not do for a policeman.”

-Florence Nightingale, 1859

Please take a moment to celebrate the nurses in your life. Florence Nightingale was the first to publicly decry the sorry reputation of nurses — as in the quote — but nurses remain vastly underappreciated for the work they do.

Let’s take a moment to consider how nurses contribute to the interdisciplinary teams in the nursing home, the hospital, the hospice, and the clinic.

I think we’ve underappreciated the role of nurses as teachers. I must give thanks first to the nurses who have taught me and continue to teach me. As a physician-in-training and now as a junior attending, nurses have taught me at least as much about clinical medicine and caring for patients as any other group except patients.

From nurses I’ve been amazed to learn what home health and hospice can accomplish at home, the limits of what can be done in the nursing home, and really practical advice like patients should lie on their left side when infusing an enema (it’s a straighter shot into the colon, if you were wondering).

Nurse practitioners were the first ones to practice gerontology and palliative care in many places, and have been the senior-most clinical mentors to many of us. During training, when we ran out of ideas for treatment of complex pain, we often turned to Maureen Lynch, the NP and senior clinician on the palliative care team for advice.

Patrice Villars is the senior clinician at the San Francisco VAMC and I routinely look to her for advice on how to approach complex and challenging patients. Nurse practitioners, being both clinicians and nurses, are uniquely able to navigate challenging issues and dynamics that arise between nurses, physicians, patients, and families.

There is an expression, “Nurses are on the front lines,” that certainly applied in Florence Nightingale’s time — she described being “up to her elbows in blood,” caring for British soldiers in the Crimean war — and still applies today.

Nurses are there, in the room, when the patient and family have stopped putting on their best face for the doctors. They have contributed to countless family meetings, as witnesses to the everyday experiences of patients and families: joy and suffering, hope and fear, loss and renewal.

And physicians, let’s stop claiming ownership of the nurses we work with, as in, “This is my nurse X.” It’s demeaning and emphasizes a hierarchy that is antithetical to highly functioning interdisciplinary teams.

Alex Smith is an Assistant Professor of Medicine, Department of Medicine, Division of Geriatrics at the University of California, San Francisco who blogs at GeriPal.

Submit a guest post and be heard.

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please read the comment policy.

  • Jesse

    Amen. As doctors are forced to spread their time between more patients as reimbursements drop, nurses are called on to have more and more responsibility.

    I am sending this to all the RNs I know!

  • madoc

    I love nurses.

  • JF Sucher, MD FACS

    I tell people to think about this:

    The phrase isn’t “I was doctored back to health”…
    It is “I was nursed back to health”.

    Nursing is the lynch pin to a good patient recovery.

    FaST Surgeon

  • Terri_g

    Nurses don’t hear this enough. Thanks for taking the time to express your thoughts and recognizing the value nurses bring to the healthcare team.

  • Anonymous

    Nurses are indeed underappreciated, even in developing countries. As a medical student, I will change the way I think about nurses. =)

Most Popular