Excessive police force, as seen in the emergency room

December 28, 2008

Emergency department physicians often observed, but did not report, cases of excessive police brutality.

MedPage Today
reports a small study that showed “even though 97.8% of emergency physician respondents said they had treated such cases, only 28.8% said they had reported them.”

However, some take exception (via GruntDoc) to that conclusion, questioning whether emergency doctors are qualified to make judgments regarding police brutality. “The fact is,” says physician John Ford, “such physicians are in no more of a position to assess appropriate force usage than are social workers or New York Times reporters.”



Related posts:

  1. Are emergency physicians best served to staff urgent care centers?
  2. Do HMOs drive blacks to the emergency room?
  3. Specialist shortages in the emergency room
  4. Nathan Lanier: Solving the emergency room crisis
  5. Police Seek ‘Professionals’ Who Removed St. Paul Man’s Testicles
  6. Emergency room specialist call
  7. "Running doctors out of the emergency room"


KevinMD.com on Facebook


  Follow on Twitter   Subscribe



{ 1 comment }

1 jb December 29, 2008 at 9:00 am

POLICE ORGANIZATION SAYS ER DOCS SOMETIMES GIVE POOR CARE TO INJURED COPS

A survey of local police personnel reveals that many of them believe that ER physicians use the wrong type of suture in closing lacerations, prescribe incorrect antibiotics, or otherwise misuse their positions as healers when caring for their colleagues. When questioned, the police spokeperson was able to cite absolutely no data to confirm these beliefs, but she stated that “Everybody says so, especially the instructors at the Police Academy.” She added that the recipients of alleged poor care were afraid to complain, because they rely of the goodwill of the ER physicians and staff to help them when they are injured while on their beats protecting the populace.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post: iPatients and the demise of the bedside physical exam

Next post: When do mid-levels help in the ER?

Site Meter