Journalism, harder than neurosurgery?

October 21, 2008

So says Andrew Cline, an assistant professor of journalism: “Journalism is not brain surgery; it’s more difficult than that.”

The Happy Hospitalist takes exeception. (via Pursuing Holiness)



Related posts:

  1. Pseduo-Journalism: Health Care Olympics
  2. Brain surgery in a day
  3. Did this ER physician refuse to treat the poor?
  4. More problems with “never” events
  5. Working harder won’t reduce medical errors
  6. Autism: "Thinking like an animal"
  7. Mid-levels as hospitalists


KevinMD.com on Facebook


  Follow on Twitter   Subscribe



{ 1 comment }

1 alexa-blue October 21, 2008 at 8:17 pm

I didn’t read the article, but Cline’s point seems to be that a journalist futilely strives for a platonic ideal of objectivity and comprehensiveness that he will never be able to obtain, thus his obstacles are essential and insurmountable, whereas a neurosurgeon’s hurdles are technical and merely finite.

Whatever. On the other hand, it’s an empirically verifiable truth that neurosurgery is a growth field, whereas journalism is dying. So, there’s that.

I should really be writing clinic notes.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post: Unintended consequences of mandates

Next post: Zero tolerance for adverse drug events

Site Meter