The fact that Canada might have use for another doctor doesn’t obviate the weight having to take on another resident who will require immediate and ongoing care financed by the citizens of that country. In case you are not aware, most countries that allow any migrations evaluate not only the occupation of the head of the family, but all the other components of that family, including handicapped individuals and the elderly.

This applicant obviously sought to bring with him his handicapped dependent daughter; her needs should be considered just as much as his potential contribution as a skilled worker.

And if you think this is stupid or unfair, just remember, doctors are not always welcome in every place, including in some surprisingly advanced places, like Australia and New Zealand.

We used to aggressively screen health of immigrants to the US and, now that we extend tax dollars to care for the poor and elderly, are stupid not to do so again.