Monday, April 30, 2007

Aging

Atul Gawande on aging and the fate of the elderly:
Despite a rapidly growing elderly population, the number of certified geriatricians fell by a third between 1998 and 2004. Applications to training programs in adult primary-care medicine are plummeting, while fields like plastic surgery and radiology receive applications in record numbers. Partly, this has to do with money—incomes in geriatrics and adult primary care are among the lowest in medicine. And partly, whether we admit it or not, most doctors don’t like taking care of the elderly . . .

. . . On average, in Boult’s study, the geriatric services cost the hospital $1,350 more per person than the savings they produced, and Medicare, the insurer for the elderly, does not cover that cost. It’s a strange double standard. No one insists that a twenty-five-thousand-dollar pacemaker or a coronary-artery stent save money for insurers. It just has to maybe do people some good. Meanwhile, the twenty-plus members of the proven geriatrics team at the University of Minnesota had to find new jobs. Scores of medical centers across the country have shrunk or closed their geriatrics units. Several of Boult’s colleagues no longer advertise their geriatric training for fear that they’ll get too many elderly patients. “Economically, it has become too difficult,” Boult said.
(via kottke)


Comments:
Considering there are 82 plastic surgery residency positions available each year, and a fixed number of post surgical fellowships, how could more people go into this field? I am not as familiar with radiology, but I assume the number of residency spots is relatively fixed as well with few left unfilled.
 
"Most Doctor's don't like taking care of the elderly"

Sounds sort of like an oxymoron doesn't it. This is the age group who needs medical care the most and the doc's dont wnat to deal with them. What do you want to deal with? The perfectly fine healthy 30 year old who shows up just for a physical to begin his new job? Is that really practicing medicine?
 
"Most Doctor's don't like taking care of the elderly"

I think that this statement is just malarky. I love taking care of the elderly. They have always been my most interesting and respectful patients. They are from an era when "Doctor" meant something worthy of respect and have a healthier attitude towards sickness and life than egocentric baby boomers like myself.

The problem, is that I hate Medicare. I love freedom and I respect my ethical obligation to privacy and quality that Medicare intrudes on. I would never seek a geriatric certification because of the government's claims to own these patients and intrude into my relationships with them.
 
Anon 6:06
I am not a doctor but I would imagine what you are saying would be like asking why a janitor wouldn't pick a college frat house as his dream job. Sure he became a janitor to clean, but this job requires an overwhelming amount of work and pays the worst (ie cheap college kids = cheap medicare)
 
On the other hand, if Medicare payed twice the going rate to take care of the elderly as commercial insurance pays for treating the young, doctors would be falling all over themselves to corner the market on this group. Geriatrics would suddenly become quite desirable and the residency slots would be over subscribed.
 
Post a Comment