RateMDs.com budges a bit

December 6, 2006

And removes two of the most offending negative MD comments:

“Clearly we do see some comments that are overly aggressive like the ones we did delete,” he said, referring to two comments one which said a doctor was “the worst of the worst. He butchered me” and another which said, “Are you planning to commit suicide? Go to this doctor and he will kill you.”



Related posts:

  1. Suicide drama on RateMDs
  2. Terms of Use Agreement and Comment Policy
  3. Terms of Use Agreement and Comment Policy
  4. Legal trouble with blog comments
  5. Physician suicide
  6. Malpractice and physician suicide
  7. Medical Justice vs RateMDs


KevinMD.com on Facebook


  Follow on Twitter   Subscribe



{ 3 comments }

1 Gasman December 6, 2006 at 2:27 pm

It does become a bit of a one sided presentation. The patient, if ever they were a patient of the doc, is permitted to make just about any allegation.
The doc, however, can offer little in rebuttal. He may not ever have had contact with the purported patient, may not recognize the patient’s pseudonym, and if they do know who is ripping them, do not have the freedom to discuss case specifics.

I have my own web tormentor. He can slander my name just this side of legally actionable, and I can offer little objective resistance on the BBS he is posting, or on any other site. Only when the patient files suit does it effectively give blanket immunity from HIPAA constraints.

2 Anonymous December 6, 2006 at 4:53 pm

The problem with information systems that allow anonymous, non-verifiable posts is that the quality of information in is poor; thus the output is equally worthless.

I just got done shilling for myself, as well as some glowing comments for some friends. And the craziest part is that none of us are MDs. As long as there are no meaningful filters to creating absolute fiction and downright lies in such databases, we should hammer home this point by adding to the fiction and lies.

3 Anonymous December 7, 2006 at 5:51 pm

This website is scary. Out of curiosity I looked up my own family doctor, and found a nasty comment insulting her weight and calling her young children “very ugly”. I guess any old whack job can say whatever they want under the veil of anonymity.

I red-flagged the comment to submit a request for review this afternoon, and I guess to their credit, the post is no longer on there. I don’t know why they let it get past their initial “vetting” process to begin with though.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post: Too many doctors are calling in antibiotics over the phone

Next post: The winners of Medgadget’s sci fi writing contest

Site Meter