Orac: "AMSA is deep into promoting woo among medical students"

November 13, 2006

Follow-up on Dr. RW’s take on how hypocritical AMSA is. How could a medical student organization be so uncritical?

On what studies or evidence does AMSA base these assertions, particularly the last one, in which AMSA explicitly states that TCM is “well-suited” to a certain group of patients? None whatsoever. The references are all books on TCM and acupuncture. There’s not a single peer-reviewed scientific study or clinical trial listed in the references for TCM. There’s not discussion of the lack of scientific evidence even for the existence of qi (and scientists have looked and continue to look; I’ve seen grant applications in which the applicants propose trying to measure qi). Moreover, there is little or no skepticism or crtitical thinking. It’s all warm and fuzzy acceptance.



Related posts:

  1. AMSA is harming medical education
  2. AMSA and the Quackometer
  3. When medical students think they know everything
  4. AMSA supports Michael Moore
  5. AMSA and the learned helplessness attitude
  6. Are medical students too liberal?
  7. Promoting medication adherence via lottery


KevinMD.com on Facebook


  Follow on Twitter   Subscribe



Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post: The five-second rule: Is it really safe to eat food off the ground?

Next post: More trouble with medical marijuana laws

Site Meter