Wednesday, August 30, 200610
A call to ban fertility treatments for the obese
Can this ever fly here?
The British Fertility Society is recommending women with a body mass index of 36 and over should not be allowed access to fertility treatment.
Underweight women and those classed just as obese (BMI over 29) should be forced to address their weight before starting treatment, the society said.
Comments
-
Samson Isberg
Applause!!
-
Anonymous
Why stop there? Let's ban fertility treatments for women with IQ's under 90 or over 120. And for anyone with the Huntington's gene. Or for anyone with a personal history or mental illness. Or even a family history. And what about husbands of women accessing fertility treatments: shouldn't they have to maintain specific BMI's as well?
-
Anonymous
I don't do fertility w/u's for these patients. They are at significant risks for complications during their pregnancy icluding, HTN, pre-eclampsia, GDM, shoulder dystocia and c-section. Why would I want to get that patient pregnant?
-
Rob
Sounds a little too close to social engineering to me. I understand the risk difference, but it is getting into a grey zone
-
Anonymous
anonymous 12:27
-
drncc
Heya Kevin,
-
radiculous
All of those UK docs who now won't have to do hysterosalpingograms on 250 lb whales must be very happy.
-
Anonymous
Not kidding -- I saw a 372 lb 14 year old girl for abdominal pain. Should I have called CPS ??
-
Anonymous
Apparently some of you failed to consider that the article singles out underweight women as well as obese ones. Its a no-brainer- being at an unhealthy weight (whether high or low) drastically reduces your capability to conceive.
-
Anonymous
About this "underweight" business: are you sure it is not just a mistake in the article? Because it doesn't seem consistent: they didn't say "underweight and overweight" or "significantly underweight and obese"; they also mentioned BMI for overweight but not for underweight.
Post a CommentApplause!!
Best idea EVER!!
Would save us OB's a lot of unnecessary stress also
11:01 AM
And why stop at fertility treatment: mandatory first trimester abortions for all fat people....
just in case you missed it, my comments are sarcastic...
11:27 AM
3:33 PM
4:21 PM
I agree with every word you said, except the part about the sarcasm.
5:20 PM
I would think the idea is that underweight or overweight screws up girly hormones.
That's a special medical term for BMI influences fertility.
Looking for medical help to conceive is a bit silly if one hasn't addressed other factors affecting fertility.
drncc
5:28 PM
9:50 AM
3:28 PM
6:02 PM
So if you take it literally, it seems like 1 pound underweight is enough for them to give you hard time, but not 1 pound overweight.
9:47 PM